| Measurements of public-key signature systems on one machine: amd64; Raptor Cove (b06a2); 2023 Intel Core i7-13700H, P cores; 6 x 4800MHz; raptor, supercop-20231107
[Page version: 20251028 08:35:44] 
eBATS
(ECRYPT Benchmarking
of Asymmetric Systems)
is a project
to measure the performance of public-key systems.
This page presents benchmark results collected in eBATS
for public-key signature systems:
 
Time (cycles) to generate a key pair:
a secret key and a corresponding public key.
Time to sign a short message (59 bytes).
Time to open a signed short message,
i.e., to verify a (larger) signed message and recover the original short message.
Space (bytes) for a secret key.
Space for a public key.
Space for a signature on a 0-byte message.
Space for a signature on a 23-byte message:
i.e.,
the signed-message length minus 23 bytes.
Space for a signature on a long message:
i.e.,
the signed-message length minus the message length.
 
For signature systems that support "message recovery",
the space for a signature on a long message
is shorter than the space for a signature on a short message.
 
Each table row lists
the first quartile of many speed measurements,
the median of many speed measurements,
the third quartile of many speed measurements, and
the name of the primitive.
Measurements with large variance are indicated in red with question marks.
The symbol
T:
(starting with supercop-20200816)
means that the SUPERCOP database
at the time of benchmarking did not list constant time
as a goal for this implementation.
The symbol
T!!!
means that constant time was listed as a goal for this implementation,
but that the implementation failed TIMECOP.
(TIMECOP failures are not necessarily security issues;
they can sometimes be resolved by, e.g., declaring that a rejection-sampling condition is safe to declassify.)
 
There is a
separate page
with more information about each signature system and each implementation.
Designers and implementors
interested in submitting new signature systems
and new implementations of existing signature systems
should read the call for submissions.
 
 Test results Graphs:
(pkcycles,pkbytes)
(smcycles,sbytes)
(mcycles,pkbytes)
(mcycles,sbytes)
(pkbytes,sbytes)
 NISTPQC graphs:
(pkcycles,pkbytes)
(smcycles,sbytes)
(mcycles,pkbytes)
(mcycles,sbytes)
(pkbytes,sbytes)
 Measurement failures: ntrumls401x, ntrumls439x, ntrumls593x, ntrumls743x, qtesla128, qtesla192, qtesla256 
| 
| 
| Cycles to generate a key pair | 
|---|
 | 25% | 50% | 75% | system | 
|---|
 | 2768 | 2777 | 2834 | picnicl1full |  | 3048 | 3088 | 3161 | picnic3l1 |  | 3900 | 3909 | 3981 | picnicl3full |  | 3911 | 3935 | 4012 | picnic3l3 |  | 4006 | 4030 | 4213 | picnicl1fs |  | 4030 | 4056 | 4228 | picnicl1ur |  | 4145 | 4299 | 4457 | T:picnic2l1fs |  | 5116 | 5157 | 5207 | picnicl5full |  | 5155 | 5192 | 5245 | picnic3l5 |  | 7540 | 7613 | 7731 | picnicl3ur |  | 8184 | 8285 | 8527 | picnicl3fs |  | 10414 | 10511 | 10679 | T:picnic2l3fs |  | 10591 | 10636 | 11408 | picnicl5ur |  | 10613 | 10652 | 10884 | picnicl5fs |  | 13172 | 13243 | 13346 | T:picnic2l5fs |  | 18070 | 18137 | 18319 | T:lattisigns512 |  | 34135 | 34286 | 34524 | dilithium2aes |  | 38691 | 39180 | 40533 | ed25519 |  | 53286 | 53510 | 54076 | dilithium3aes |  | 75575 | 75882 | 76474 | dilithium2 |  | 79205 | 79989 | 80768 | dilithium5aes |  | 128388 | 128994 | 129719 | T:ed448goldilocks |  | 139987 | 140470 | 141186 | dilithium3 |  | 205545 | 206400 | 209779 | T:pass769 |  | 217077 | 217754 | 218918 | dilithium5 |  | 239796 | 241572 | 242574 | T:pass863 |  | 439555 | 441877 | 447127 | T:sphincsf128harakasimple |  | 512238 | 515429 | 520478 | T:sphincsf128harakarobust |  | 543949 | 546198 | 547786 | T:mqdss48 |  | 618623 | 626023 | 637780 | T:edons128k08n72nu8l4mu3 |  | 616125 | 637205 | 651694 | T:sphincsf192harakasimple |  | 702148 | 713531 | 724768 | T:donald2048 |  | 776586 | 779508 | 784439 | T:sphincsf192harakarobust |  | 904533? | 1194141? | 1487608? | T:qtesla1 |  | 1259881 | 1264434 | 1272389 | T:mqdss64 |  | 1662051 | 1681211 | 1691176 | T:sphincsf256harakasimple |  | 1889697 | 1934964 | 1988544 | T:edons128ref |  | 2073977 | 2096741 | 2131207 | T:sphincsf256harakarobust |  | 2401225 | 2405105 | 2414240 | T:sphincs256 |  | 2083034? | 3064709? | 4030310? | T:qtesla3f |  | 3241850 | 3246920 | 3256749 | T:sphincsf128shake256simple |  | 4282841 | 4298406 | 4371812 | T:luov863256 |  | 4794524 | 4799528 | 4805331 | T:sphincsf192shake256simple |  | 4364006? | 4947201? | 5583223? | T:qtesla1p |  | 4095050? | 5102922? | 7098770? | T:qtesla3s |  | 5953247 | 5965357 | 5973613 | T:sphincsf128shake256robust |  | 7860802 | 7874376 | 7898175 | T:luov863256pc |  | 7890736 | 7907260 | 7930726 | T:rainbowbinary256181212 |  | 8858492 | 8881812 | 8944185 | T:sphincsf192shake256robust |  | 12212443 | 12228014 | 12265657 | T:rainbow1aclassic363232 |  | 12456222 | 12462260 | 12477474 | T:sphincsf256shake256simple |  | 12774311 | 12796850 | 12820506 | T:rainbow1acompres363232 |  | 12809233 | 12862260 | 12894630 | T:rainbow1acyclicc363232 |  | 13447123 | 13960484 | 15120903 | T:falcon512tree |  | 13927539 | 14064809 | 14203508 | T:sphincss128harakasimple |  | 14130769 | 15134324 | 16327531 | T:falcon512dyn |  | 16234382 | 16302705 | 16397538 | T:sphincss128harakarobust |  | 18923480 | 19024056 | 19171236 | T:luov4849242 |  | 19948715 | 20105958 | 20244745 | T:sphincss192harakasimple |  | 20543675 | 20588040 | 20627263 | T:luov890351 |  | 22936671 | 23030015 | 23062949 | T:sphincsf256shake256robust |  | 24864735 | 24905903 | 24950111 | T:sphincss192harakarobust |  | 26800581 | 26868601 | 26956079 | T:sphincss256harakasimple |  | 23863963? | 27683418? | 36866059? | T:qtesla3p |  | 33553517 | 33719157 | 33798234 | T:sphincss256harakarobust |  | 35095322 | 35122137 | 35273658 | T:luov890351pc |  | 35586413 | 35659420 | 35865218 | T:luov8117404 |  | 41982566 | 42082020 | 42205646 | T:rainbowbinary16242020 |  | 43807864 | 45195565 | 47774245 | T:falcon1024tree |  | 46608331 | 46751212 | 46879697 | T:gemss128v2 |  | 44504741 | 46864292 | 49919315 | T:falcon1024dyn |  | 48327367 | 48415376 | 48584561 | T:redgemss128v2 |  | 48885531 | 49046543 | 49248685 | T:bluegemss128v2 |  | 57934496 | 58079229 | 58250463 | T:luov6468330 |  | 61279786 | 61436236 | 61660493 | T:luov8117404pc |  | 64098602 | 64467553 | 64711147 | T:gemss128 |  | 66254429 | 66454359 | 66688520 | T:bluegemss128 |  | 67251675 | 67555592 | 67775931 | T:redgemss128 |  | 76612923 | 76918033 | 77756069 | T:rainbow3cclassic683248 |  | 78320510 | 78499671 | 78702061 | T:rainbow3ccompres683248 |  | 80183635 | 80255275 | 80589403 | T:rainbow3ccyclicc683248 |  | 102501605 | 102529142 | 103176913 | T:sphincss128shake256simple |  | 114266737 | 114404512 | 114726260 | T:luov8086399 |  | 130087157 | 131586108 | 132980365 | T:sflashv2 |  | 152427718 | 152462050 | 153167075 | T:sphincss192shake256simple |  | 188747468 | 189264874 | 189395520 | T:sphincss128shake256robust |  | 189398464 | 189765147 | 192708009 | T:redgemss192 |  | 199780346 | 199986571 | 200123260 | T:sphincss256shake256simple |  | 222551517 | 222637383 | 222778063 | T:rainbow5ccompres963664 |  | 227627418 | 230891259 | 233629507 | T:gemss192v2 |  | 230784589 | 231024459 | 232215601 | T:rainbow5cclassic963664 |  | 230576440 | 231477301 | 232662805 | T:redgemss192v2 |  | 230199706 | 233300656 | 234632803 | T:bluegemss192v2 |  | 236523402 | 236641099 | 236828317 | T:rainbow5ccyclicc963664 |  | 276676918 | 278935273 | 279910668 | T:gemss192 |  | 280619948 | 281230117 | 281399696 | T:sphincss192shake256robust |  | 279301108 | 281293946 | 282961663 | T:bluegemss192 |  | 365948774 | 366510147 | 366970178 | T:sphincss256shake256robust |  | 542336918 | 545291408 | 553147823 | T:redgemss256 |  | 547817993 | 549067762 | 561104143 | T:bluegemss256 |  | 687262813 | 694444389 | 702674868 | T:gemss256v2 |  | 697021494 | 698932531 | 709672716 | T:redgemss256v2 |  | 699398693 | 706476956 | 713580537 | T:bluegemss256v2 |  | 787043911 | 791019706 | 793466539 | T:gemss256 |  | 863755637 | 864061655 | 864460614 | T:gravitysphincss |  | 3031838800 | 3083973541 | 3165948851 | T:pqrsa15 |  | 13781164189 | 13785958930 | 13799124947 | T:gravitysphincsl |  | 27623496574 | 27632440165 | 27637549078 | T:gravitysphincsm |  | 
| Cycles to sign 59 bytes | 
|---|
 | 25% | 50% | 75% | system | 
|---|
 | 11588 | 11845 | 12505 | T:rainbowbinary256181212 |  | 26703 | 27163 | 27858 | T:rainbowbinary16242020 |  | 41207 | 41602 | 42017 | ed25519 |  | 62673 | 62912 | 63316 | T:rainbow1aclassic363232 |  | 83016 | 83496 | 84498 | T:sflashv2 |  | 93106 | 94181 | 95966 | T:rainbow1acyclicc363232 |  | 63592? | 106999? | 184004? | dilithium2aes |  | 134311 | 134914 | 135509 | T:ed448goldilocks |  | 110111? | 153120? | 238061? | dilithium3aes |  | 108083? | 182362? | 291326? | dilithium2 |  | 158413? | 207790? | 285301? | dilithium5aes |  | 187423? | 276967? | 457787? | T:lattisigns512 |  | 271047? | 282917? | 552216? | T:pass769 |  | 142553? | 294923? | 472702? | T:qtesla1 |  | 220078? | 312859? | 429472? | dilithium3 |  | 314449 | 317821 | 324270 | T:rainbow3cclassic683248 |  | 329132 | 334949 | 338059 | T:falcon512tree |  | 334354 | 340310 | 347051 | T:rainbow3ccyclicc683248 |  | 347874 | 350279 | 355574 | T:luov863256pc |  | 321946? | 423254? | 595153? | dilithium5 |  | 311322? | 526333? | 738839? | T:qtesla3f |  | 569030 | 572381 | 584018 | T:falcon512dyn |  | 314333? | 624838? | 942193? | T:pass863 |  | 660841 | 669125 | 683434 | T:falcon1024tree |  | 493691? | 688566? | 1199934? | T:qtesla1p |  | 706433 | 713683 | 723016 | T:donald2048 |  | 395761? | 736836? | 1357905? | T:qtesla3s |  | 750214 | 762339 | 774350 | T:rainbow5cclassic963664 |  | 791712 | 848116 | 864498 | T:rainbow5ccyclicc963664 |  | 1047670 | 1060660 | 1100581 | T:edons128k08n72nu8l4mu3 |  | 1145836 | 1150442 | 1161248 | T:luov890351pc |  | 1145187 | 1154232 | 1162727 | T:falcon1024dyn |  | 1634835 | 1644858 | 1658359 | T:luov8117404pc |  | 2155117? | 2421089? | 4201647? | T:qtesla3p |  | 2082512? | 2509332? | 3013511? | T:redgemss128 |  | 2324287? | 2654936? | 3333707? | T:redgemss128v2 |  | 2811612 | 2843165 | 2870476 | T:edons128ref |  | 3484551 | 3488210 | 3495685 | T:luov863256 |  | 3555604 | 3558123 | 3562492 | picnicl1full |  | 3534835 | 3767242 | 3856521 | T:mqdss48 |  | 4120483 | 4128186 | 4137724 | picnicl1fs |  | 5414178 | 5425022 | 5430900 | picnicl1ur |  | 4780302? | 5821760? | 6875765? | T:redgemss192 |  | 6081103 | 6089016 | 6097815 | T:gravitysphincss |  | 5662771? | 6559454? | 7524392? | T:redgemss192v2 |  | 6958461 | 6966573 | 6980840 | picnicl3full |  | 8706849 | 8758100 | 8790099 | T:mqdss64 |  | 7793416? | 8995489? | 10812016? | T:redgemss256 |  | 10109710 | 10117748 | 10124365 | picnicl3fs |  | 10204694 | 10224366 | 10254879 | T:rainbow1acompres363232 |  | 9316810? | 10840689? | 13560926? | T:redgemss256v2 |  | 11448926 | 11455606 | 11475832 | picnicl5full |  | 11503807 | 11527545 | 11551400 | T:luov890351 |  | 11719735 | 11750412 | 11814931 | T:gravitysphincsm |  | 13856802 | 13872130 | 13901038 | picnicl3ur |  | 14065469 | 14092325 | 14156311 | T:gravitysphincsl |  | 15348073 | 15379846 | 15421648 | picnic3l1 |  | 16053799 | 16094707 | 16130423 | T:sphincsf128harakasimple |  | 17701693 | 17707865 | 17763041 | picnicl5fs |  | 18814909 | 18945093 | 19013608 | T:sphincsf192harakasimple |  | 19370544 | 19443500 | 19527318 | T:sphincsf128harakarobust |  | 19902129 | 19933563 | 19973858 | T:luov8117404 |  | 23080844 | 23093840 | 23135785 | picnicl5ur |  | 24256628 | 24307447 | 24375791 | T:sphincsf192harakarobust |  | 32907068 | 32953916 | 33003256 | picnic3l3 |  | 37360629 | 37422695 | 37520819 | T:luov4849242 |  | 42866744 | 42911350 | 42958532 | T:sphincs256 |  | 43284149 | 43404013 | 43554600 | T:sphincsf256harakasimple |  | 54900018 | 54983281 | 56697835 | picnic3l5 |  | 56363683 | 56453754 | 56580447 | T:sphincsf256harakarobust |  | 62617253 | 62680094 | 62740087 | T:rainbow3ccompres683248 |  | 62001192? | 74432299? | 98861566? | T:bluegemss128v2 |  | 66737765? | 80102367? | 93591850? | T:bluegemss128 |  | 103938529 | 104060778 | 104203783 | T:pqrsa15 |  | 105082790 | 105165022 | 105238439 | T:sphincsf128shake256simple |  | 111418817 | 111757821 | 111883932 | T:luov6468330 |  | 134087986 | 134294624 | 134444708 | T:sphincsf192shake256simple |  | 139305092 | 139515068 | 140393485 | T:picnic2l1fs |  | 152368070 | 152489241 | 152841232 | T:rainbow5ccompres963664 |  | 184069654 | 184217299 | 184392523 | T:sphincsf128shake256robust |  | 165950498? | 198396508? | 231549918? | T:bluegemss192v2 |  | 167018263? | 200036565? | 234386002? | T:bluegemss192 |  | 216380112 | 216819745 | 222966205 | T:luov8086399 |  | 242803671 | 243039764 | 243760947 | T:sphincsf192shake256robust |  | 269477962 | 270262648 | 271096444 | T:sphincss128harakasimple |  | 290876448 | 291046262 | 291660420 | T:sphincsf256shake256simple |  | 262905086? | 315531906? | 368647562? | T:bluegemss256v2 |  | 327441160 | 327811826 | 328766938 | T:sphincss128harakarobust |  | 279353282? | 334497174? | 391244343? | T:bluegemss256 |  | 377632904 | 378193379 | 380792038 | T:sphincss256harakasimple |  | 377143614 | 378459118 | 454422433 | T:gemss128v2 |  | 415035975 | 415600312 | 416834824 | T:picnic2l3fs |  | 408655911? | 485202742? | 573035397? | T:gemss128 |  | 493667350 | 494185116 | 494671309 | T:sphincss256harakarobust |  | 520171527 | 520748590 | 520979567 | T:sphincsf256shake256robust |  | 581797526 | 582897164 | 586204736 | T:sphincss192harakasimple |  | 793395802 | 794219463 | 795883938 | T:sphincss192harakarobust |  | 879929030 | 880954559 | 894281781 | T:picnic2l5fs |  | 1150542148? | 1382635323? | 1618700472? | T:gemss192v2 |  | 1181853361? | 1418490271? | 1664252222? | T:gemss192 |  | 1643002562 | 1644225372 | 1650086496 | T:sphincss128shake256simple |  | 1888157114? | 2265716813? | 2644601874? | T:gemss256v2 |  | 2441566927 | 2444434531 | 2445249799 | T:sphincss256shake256simple |  | 2817919199 | 2827215678 | 2831606430 | T:sphincss128shake256robust |  | 2056674371? | 2831882754? | 2868175310? | T:gemss256 |  | 3502683712 | 3503539265 | 3505130463 | T:sphincss192shake256simple |  | 4298807304 | 4308536105 | 4311408974 | T:sphincss256shake256robust |  | 5884036578 | 5899232712 | 5900583818 | T:sphincss192shake256robust |  | 
| Cycles to verify 59 bytes | 
|---|
 | 25% | 50% | 75% | system | 
|---|
 | 8644 | 8998 | 9188 | T:rainbowbinary256181212 |  | 20009 | 20255 | 20476 | T:rainbowbinary16242020 |  | 23258 | 24460 | 25388 | T:rainbow1aclassic363232 |  | 28948 | 29247 | 29511 | T:lattisigns512 |  | 44766 | 44916 | 45095 | dilithium2aes |  | 53241 | 54936 | 56938 | T:gravitysphincss |  | 54272 | 55471 | 55803 | T:falcon512tree |  | 63069 | 63257 | 63693 | dilithium3aes |  | 64461 | 65111 | 66489 | T:qtesla1 |  | 64960 | 65441 | 66325 | T:falcon512dyn |  | 70625 | 71052 | 71488 | T:sflashv2 |  | 83171 | 83361 | 83510 | dilithium2 |  | 82768 | 84555 | 88930 | T:luov863256pc |  | 92269 | 92545 | 93017 | dilithium5aes |  | 109268 | 110715 | 111273 | T:falcon1024tree |  | 123502 | 130098 | 140400 | T:rainbow3cclassic683248 |  | 130169 | 130927 | 131562 | T:falcon1024dyn |  | 130550 | 131321 | 132707 | ed25519 |  | 138497 | 138698 | 139044 | dilithium3 |  | 137702 | 138745 | 139258 | T:qtesla3f |  | 139378 | 140267 | 140984 | T:qtesla3s |  | 223120 | 224848 | 225364 | dilithium5 |  | 234754 | 238223 | 243928 | T:gravitysphincsm |  | 238842 | 251062 | 257955 | T:redgemss128 |  | 261608 | 274983 | 291593 | T:bluegemss128v2 |  | 266495 | 275976 | 290932 | T:gemss128 |  | 275603 | 280026 | 287971 | T:redgemss128v2 |  | 275800 | 284752 | 304320 | T:gemss128v2 |  | 266172 | 286048 | 303318 | T:bluegemss128 |  | 312252 | 313865 | 315063 | T:qtesla1p |  | 315990 | 316726 | 319153 | T:pass769 |  | 315807 | 321118 | 326607 | T:gravitysphincsl |  | 328500 | 340434 | 357598 | T:luov890351pc |  | 359428 | 366345 | 380702 | T:rainbow5cclassic963664 |  | 365642 | 367353 | 368888 | T:pass863 |  | 364612 | 371371 | 379928 | T:sphincss128harakasimple |  | 372223 | 374729 | 380429 | T:edons128k08n72nu8l4mu3 |  | 431793 | 434293 | 438172 | T:ed448goldilocks |  | 490423 | 502491 | 514769 | T:luov8117404pc |  | 537344 | 548948 | 554594 | T:sphincss128harakarobust |  | 541212 | 550361 | 564818 | T:sphincss192harakasimple |  | 538349 | 564852 | 611417 | T:redgemss192 |  | 618276 | 648468 | 696802 | T:redgemss192v2 |  | 654511 | 680457 | 727559 | T:bluegemss192v2 |  | 645129 | 683597 | 724565 | T:bluegemss192 |  | 662956 | 693428 | 723691 | T:gemss192v2 |  | 651611 | 698391 | 728648 | T:gemss192 |  | 799892 | 813541 | 871276 | T:sphincss256harakasimple |  | 838978 | 845926 | 854829 | T:donald2048 |  | 851456 | 862552 | 876696 | T:sphincsf128harakasimple |  | 875477 | 882640 | 897251 | T:edons128ref |  | 891031 | 909278 | 919100 | T:sphincss192harakarobust |  | 1239056 | 1252976 | 1272198 | T:sphincss256harakarobust |  | 1247288 | 1256542 | 1264921 | T:sphincs256 |  | 1250616 | 1271730 | 1293272 | T:sphincsf128harakarobust |  | 1212372 | 1272202 | 1479549 | T:bluegemss256 |  | 1235426 | 1278406 | 1433530 | T:redgemss256 |  | 1328523 | 1341190 | 1351911 | T:sphincsf192harakasimple |  | 1284895 | 1365106 | 1504964 | T:bluegemss256v2 |  | 1353375? | 1458142? | 1856505? | T:gemss256 |  | 1383897 | 1466254 | 1541364 | T:redgemss256v2 |  | 1520784 | 1535115 | 1545943 | T:sphincsf256harakasimple |  | 1511432 | 1578549 | 1676589 | T:gemss256v2 |  | 1583415 | 1588978 | 1596124 | T:qtesla3p |  | 2172408 | 2190879 | 2211360 | T:sphincsf192harakarobust |  | 2381009 | 2405312 | 2425262 | T:sphincsf256harakarobust |  | 2395048 | 2442178 | 2501615 | T:sphincss128shake256simple |  | 2270954 | 2446209 | 2502218 | T:mqdss48 |  | 2796622 | 2798506 | 2814420 | T:luov863256 |  | 2804817 | 2809923 | 2822337 | picnicl1full |  | 3301392 | 3317587 | 3327255 | picnicl1fs |  | 3559227 | 3623601 | 3688373 | T:sphincss192shake256simple |  | 4374445 | 4394735 | 4409763 | picnicl1ur |  | 4568755 | 4682685 | 4761170 | T:sphincss256shake256simple |  | 4542075 | 4705846 | 4822010 | T:sphincss128shake256robust |  | 5276619 | 5343401 | 5465656 | T:sphincsf128shake256simple |  | 5594328 | 5601886 | 5612236 | picnicl3full |  | 5894795 | 5920294 | 5972963 | T:mqdss64 |  | 6816726 | 6988246 | 7109345 | T:sphincss192shake256robust |  | 8003131 | 8019973 | 8131230 | T:rainbow1acompres363232 |  | 8014558 | 8025934 | 8035029 | T:rainbow1acyclicc363232 |  | 8310753 | 8401485 | 8502624 | T:sphincsf256shake256simple |  | 8436096 | 8448842 | 8462197 | picnicl3fs |  | 8414093 | 8490061 | 8564668 | T:sphincsf192shake256simple |  | 8742658 | 8881287 | 8999213 | T:sphincss256shake256robust |  | 9240949 | 9252931 | 9282532 | picnicl5full |  | 9974190 | 9989233 | 10028114 | T:luov890351 |  | 10218152 | 10371013 | 10512949 | T:sphincsf128shake256robust |  | 11210745 | 11254827 | 11285183 | picnicl3ur |  | 11844478 | 11870157 | 11888759 | picnic3l1 |  | 13908204 | 13932366 | 13999945 | T:pqrsa15 |  | 14384713 | 14407728 | 14446420 | picnicl5fs |  | 16260735 | 16383295 | 16578803 | T:sphincsf256shake256robust |  | 16303156 | 16438933 | 16568851 | T:sphincsf192shake256robust |  | 17100873 | 17129036 | 17171793 | T:luov8117404 |  | 18775161 | 18795084 | 18855895 | picnicl5ur |  | 25676810 | 25728254 | 25780405 | picnic3l3 |  | 28973007 | 28986251 | 29026959 | T:luov4849242 |  | 40469032 | 40518579 | 40621238 | picnic3l5 |  | 48667156 | 48713114 | 48881343 | T:rainbow3ccompres683248 |  | 48763925 | 48795737 | 48838601 | T:rainbow3ccyclicc683248 |  | 65194621 | 65290916 | 65459406 | T:picnic2l1fs |  | 73242517 | 73311887 | 73410271 | T:luov6468330 |  | 109380361 | 109532467 | 109600306 | T:rainbow5ccyclicc963664 |  | 109734168 | 109878524 | 110298151 | T:rainbow5ccompres963664 |  | 144946722 | 145115278 | 148712356 | T:luov8086399 |  | 147985654 | 148156311 | 148276921 | T:picnic2l3fs |  | 261746542 | 262209236 | 262784939 | T:picnic2l5fs |  | 
 |  |