| Measurements of public-key signature systems on one machine: amd64; Ice Lake (706e5); 2019 Intel Core i3-1035G1; 4 x 1000MHz; icelake2, supercop-20221005
[Page version: 20251028 08:35:44] 
eBATS
(ECRYPT Benchmarking
of Asymmetric Systems)
is a project
to measure the performance of public-key systems.
This page presents benchmark results collected in eBATS
for public-key signature systems:
 
Time (cycles) to generate a key pair:
a secret key and a corresponding public key.
Time to sign a short message (59 bytes).
Time to open a signed short message,
i.e., to verify a (larger) signed message and recover the original short message.
Space (bytes) for a secret key.
Space for a public key.
Space for a signature on a 0-byte message.
Space for a signature on a 23-byte message:
i.e.,
the signed-message length minus 23 bytes.
Space for a signature on a long message:
i.e.,
the signed-message length minus the message length.
 
For signature systems that support "message recovery",
the space for a signature on a long message
is shorter than the space for a signature on a short message.
 
Each table row lists
the first quartile of many speed measurements,
the median of many speed measurements,
the third quartile of many speed measurements, and
the name of the primitive.
Measurements with large variance are indicated in red with question marks.
The symbol
T:
(starting with supercop-20200816)
means that the SUPERCOP database
at the time of benchmarking did not list constant time
as a goal for this implementation.
The symbol
T!!!
means that constant time was listed as a goal for this implementation,
but that the implementation failed TIMECOP.
(TIMECOP failures are not necessarily security issues;
they can sometimes be resolved by, e.g., declaring that a rejection-sampling condition is safe to declassify.)
 
There is a
separate page
with more information about each signature system and each implementation.
Designers and implementors
interested in submitting new signature systems
and new implementations of existing signature systems
should read the call for submissions.
 
 Test results Graphs:
(pkcycles,pkbytes)
(smcycles,sbytes)
(mcycles,pkbytes)
(mcycles,sbytes)
(pkbytes,sbytes)
 NISTPQC graphs:
(pkcycles,pkbytes)
(smcycles,sbytes)
(mcycles,pkbytes)
(mcycles,sbytes)
(pkbytes,sbytes)
 Measurement failures: ntrumls401x, ntrumls439x, ntrumls593x, ntrumls743x, qtesla128, qtesla192, qtesla256 
| 
| 
| Cycles to generate a key pair | 
|---|
 | 25% | 50% | 75% | system | 
|---|
 | 2557 | 2586 | 2766 | picnic3l1 |  | 2583 | 2616 | 2707 | picnicl1full |  | 3468 | 3496 | 3545 | picnicl1fs |  | 3480 | 3497 | 3565 | picnicl3full |  | 3499 | 3527 | 3583 | picnicl1ur |  | 3640 | 3666 | 3779 | picnic3l3 |  | 3467? | 3682? | 5317? | T:picnic2l1fs |  | 4543 | 4636 | 5066 | picnicl5full |  | 4789 | 4852 | 5022 | picnic3l5 |  | 5789 | 5931 | 6242 | T:picnic2l3fs |  | 5943 | 6022 | 6154 | picnicl3ur |  | 5971 | 6036 | 6238 | picnicl3fs |  | 8244 | 8329 | 8585 | picnicl5fs |  | 8484? | 8895? | 12711? | picnicl5ur |  | 8399 | 8919 | 9065 | T:picnic2l5fs |  | 20342 | 20424 | 20495 | T:lattisigns512 |  | 39586 | 39724 | 39963 | dilithium2aes |  | 49167 | 49409 | 49818 | ed25519 |  | 61183 | 61765 | 62108 | dilithium3aes |  | 74388 | 74596 | 75167 | dilithium2 |  | 89023 | 89428 | 89874 | dilithium5aes |  | 135008 | 135546 | 136471 | dilithium3 |  | 145757 | 146151 | 146539 | T:ed448goldilocks |  | 181915? | 185812? | 261604? | T:pass769 |  | 205921 | 206379 | 207500 | dilithium5 |  | 212322? | 215167? | 310924? | T:pass863 |  | 629935 | 632600 | 636193 | T:sphincsf128harakasimple |  | 654044 | 663761 | 672049 | T:edons128k08n72nu8l4mu3 |  | 710453 | 712503 | 716836 | T:mqdss48 |  | 711563 | 713830 | 716143 | T:sphincsf128harakarobust |  | 853245 | 863227 | 878264 | T:donald2048 |  | 861850 | 865805 | 870785 | T:sphincsf192harakasimple |  | 1024355 | 1027720 | 1030361 | T:sphincsf192harakarobust |  | 1071075? | 1436558? | 2081548? | T:qtesla1 |  | 1655462 | 1658377 | 1663114 | T:mqdss64 |  | 1993935 | 2018388 | 2045286 | T:edons128ref |  | 2307949 | 2316209 | 2324106 | T:sphincs256 |  | 2490477 | 2496661 | 2504875 | T:sphincsf256harakasimple |  | 2881293 | 2885814 | 2891583 | T:sphincsf256harakarobust |  | 3043465 | 3053637 | 3080575 | T:sphincsf128shake256simple |  | 2289395? | 3362116? | 4460522? | T:qtesla3f |  | 3410658? | 4576161? | 7759886? | T:qtesla3s |  | 4550981 | 4583873 | 4617110 | T:luov863256 |  | 4609415 | 4631482 | 4665875 | T:sphincsf192shake256simple |  | 4398837? | 5087678? | 6408856? | T:qtesla1p |  | 5274388 | 5287075 | 5305099 | T:sphincsf128shake256robust |  | 7290920 | 7302719 | 7314862 | T:luov863256pc |  | 8130268 | 8142651 | 8203077 | T:sphincsf192shake256robust |  | 9151975 | 9229375 | 9307793 | T:rainbowbinary256181212 |  | 12310827 | 12330358 | 12521117 | T:sphincsf256shake256simple |  | 15717972 | 15782263 | 15850056 | T:rainbow1aclassic363232 |  | 15886672 | 15952375 | 15992205 | T:rainbow1acompres363232 |  | 15938887 | 15996949 | 16125719 | T:rainbow1acyclicc363232 |  | 17305557 | 17323074 | 17504355 | T:luov890351 |  | 17418098 | 17988154 | 20349740 | T:falcon512tree |  | 17285019 | 18510897 | 19785420 | T:falcon512dyn |  | 19659590 | 19684618 | 19726841 | T:sphincss128harakasimple |  | 20874492 | 20956901 | 21010774 | T:luov4849242 |  | 21746545 | 21758568 | 21776766 | T:sphincsf256shake256robust |  | 22581779 | 22600053 | 22624250 | T:sphincss128harakarobust |  | 26478355 | 26519125 | 26565961 | T:luov890351pc |  | 22306864? | 28424761? | 34619307? | T:qtesla3p |  | 28627545 | 28668731 | 28777360 | T:sphincss192harakasimple |  | 29760141 | 29785599 | 29950935 | T:luov8117404 |  | 31930424 | 31971861 | 32011480 | T:sphincss192harakarobust |  | 37419705 | 37444196 | 37681402 | T:sphincss256harakasimple |  | 38894051 | 39979363 | 40125583 | T:rainbowbinary16242020 |  | 44002387 | 44048415 | 44084449 | T:sphincss256harakarobust |  | 48236503 | 48285217 | 48376988 | T:luov8117404pc |  | 55261069 | 57525613 | 62686739 | T:falcon1024dyn |  | 55595842 | 57802297 | 60208815 | T:falcon1024tree |  | 62738641 | 62893879 | 63005572 | T:luov6468330 |  | 66228080 | 66392120 | 66498939 | T:gemss128 |  | 67781340 | 67852164 | 68029308 | T:bluegemss128 |  | 73716305 | 73750288 | 73881897 | T:redgemss128 |  | 86063544 | 86102995 | 86246794 | T:gemss128v2 |  | 87197852 | 87619541 | 89152088 | T:rainbow3cclassic683248 |  | 88863352 | 88994303 | 89178329 | T:bluegemss128v2 |  | 91218198 | 91316990 | 91473057 | T:redgemss128v2 |  | 94068914 | 94231266 | 94384117 | T:rainbow3ccompres683248 |  | 94352317 | 95445368 | 96004831 | T:rainbow3ccyclicc683248 |  | 97706439 | 97770386 | 98074649 | T:sphincss128shake256simple |  | 118506903 | 118737354 | 118955600 | T:luov8086399 |  | 144573518 | 144826311 | 145977986 | T:sphincss192shake256simple |  | 158504173 | 158661221 | 165845092 | T:sflashv2 |  | 168012847 | 168238020 | 168351992 | T:sphincss128shake256robust |  | 197457510 | 197758009 | 200659337 | T:sphincss256shake256simple |  | 262822568 | 263235809 | 263558054 | T:sphincss192shake256robust |  | 266390167 | 266599454 | 266965862 | T:rainbow5cclassic963664 |  | 275264679 | 276074531 | 276260892 | T:rainbow5ccompres963664 |  | 275064394 | 276868741 | 277615143 | T:rainbow5ccyclicc963664 |  | 287170272 | 287397232 | 287713289 | T:gemss192 |  | 288434058 | 288913981 | 289654684 | T:bluegemss192 |  | 290304326 | 290495972 | 291176414 | T:redgemss192 |  | 342553379 | 342988309 | 344254329 | T:sphincss256shake256robust |  | 359611680 | 360318573 | 360753169 | T:gemss192v2 |  | 365808295 | 366193627 | 366774799 | T:bluegemss192v2 |  | 370482125 | 370960739 | 371857645 | T:redgemss192v2 |  | 781378701 | 781794123 | 782305316 | T:gravitysphincss |  | 782963746 | 783978245 | 785090636 | T:gemss256 |  | 791153357 | 793011557 | 797812550 | T:bluegemss256 |  | 793240553 | 802057428 | 809696451 | T:redgemss256 |  | 1002986778 | 1004279879 | 1006702454 | T:gemss256v2 |  | 1019005069 | 1020361697 | 1027131030 | T:bluegemss256v2 |  | 1022194413 | 1028805370 | 1040448151 | T:redgemss256v2 |  | 4023018842 | 4159701004 | 4232481662 | T:pqrsa15 |  | 12503466470 | 12508076751 | 12513952988 | T:gravitysphincsl |  | 24992848506 | 25024987813 | 25038489774 | T:gravitysphincsm |  | 
| Cycles to sign 59 bytes | 
|---|
 | 25% | 50% | 75% | system | 
|---|
 | 13474 | 13635 | 14229 | T:rainbowbinary256181212 |  | 25186 | 25509 | 25897 | T:rainbowbinary16242020 |  | 52628 | 52924 | 53200 | ed25519 |  | 67621 | 68314 | 69294 | T:rainbow1acyclicc363232 |  | 64523 | 68371 | 75117 | T:rainbow1aclassic363232 |  | 75000 | 77059 | 79737 | T:sflashv2 |  | 71129? | 126563? | 189677? | dilithium2aes |  | 153139 | 153530 | 154053 | T:ed448goldilocks |  | 139292? | 154505? | 279434? | dilithium2 |  | 122763? | 165211? | 258741? | dilithium3aes |  | 130495? | 177205? | 328256? | dilithium5aes |  | 254364 | 255590 | 258935 | T:luov863256pc |  | 144851? | 281123? | 417264? | T:lattisigns512 |  | 174828? | 292004? | 504766? | T:qtesla1 |  | 219135? | 298524? | 446378? | dilithium3 |  | 229685? | 299498? | 635432? | T:pass769 |  | 303314 | 304687 | 308040 | T:rainbow3cclassic683248 |  | 248735? | 322637? | 503443? | T:pass863 |  | 357200 | 360299 | 363317 | T:falcon512tree |  | 254285? | 373511? | 496671? | dilithium5 |  | 222152? | 373823? | 737533? | T:qtesla3f |  | 394335 | 395303 | 397433 | T:rainbow3ccyclicc683248 |  | 654517 | 662601 | 669703 | T:falcon512dyn |  | 424428? | 672914? | 1104323? | T:qtesla1p |  | 711641 | 720358 | 725172 | T:luov890351pc |  | 715894 | 720548 | 723012 | T:falcon1024tree |  | 746111 | 748735 | 754301 | T:rainbow5cclassic963664 |  | 855799 | 861337 | 873421 | T:donald2048 |  | 938694 | 941392 | 944793 | T:rainbow5ccyclicc963664 |  | 335765? | 1009387? | 1610541? | T:qtesla3s |  | 1043994 | 1047559 | 1056472 | T:luov8117404pc |  | 1100532 | 1110200 | 1129700 | T:edons128k08n72nu8l4mu3 |  | 1303695 | 1309089 | 1317480 | T:falcon1024dyn |  | 2598766 | 2611349 | 2654233 | T:edons128ref |  | 2006160? | 2671433? | 4435780? | T:qtesla3p |  | 2799943 | 2801913 | 2807534 | picnicl1full |  | 2778886? | 3309362? | 4054673? | T:redgemss128v2 |  | 3338118 | 3340936 | 3344126 | T:luov863256 |  | 3427283 | 3430038 | 3438739 | picnicl1fs |  | 2815099? | 3539991? | 4053779? | T:redgemss128 |  | 4392712 | 4396258 | 4403412 | picnicl1ur |  | 4468700 | 4475601 | 4483611 | T:mqdss48 |  | 5421261 | 5429629 | 5433360 | picnicl3full |  | 5461522 | 5478194 | 5578652 | T:gravitysphincss |  | 6692421? | 7903996? | 9212838? | T:redgemss192 |  | 7948671 | 7961005 | 7974544 | picnicl3fs |  | 6764309? | 7988234? | 9853355? | T:redgemss192v2 |  | 9105851 | 9114996 | 9124714 | picnicl5full |  | 10499887 | 10506320 | 10515330 | picnicl3ur |  | 10558967 | 10570068 | 10580250 | T:gravitysphincsm |  | 10631379 | 10653646 | 10662961 | T:mqdss64 |  | 11153755 | 11165733 | 11193426 | T:luov890351 |  | 10932531? | 11845337? | 15118777? | T:redgemss256v2 |  | 12510849 | 12676812 | 12899756 | T:rainbow1acompres363232 |  | 12734053 | 12757429 | 12777575 | T:gravitysphincsl |  | 13118387 | 13131530 | 13150316 | picnic3l1 |  | 13980259 | 13995997 | 14013254 | picnicl5fs |  | 11401343? | 15568116? | 17491043? | T:redgemss256 |  | 17810888 | 17827067 | 17849678 | picnicl5ur |  | 18923989 | 18959660 | 18968949 | T:luov8117404 |  | 21815268 | 21864298 | 21916691 | T:sphincsf128harakasimple |  | 25233842 | 25285936 | 25332348 | T:sphincsf192harakasimple |  | 25631363 | 25666791 | 25697345 | T:sphincsf128harakarobust |  | 27606713 | 27624473 | 27687831 | picnic3l3 |  | 30942228 | 30969226 | 31002065 | T:sphincsf192harakarobust |  | 39762064 | 40132823 | 40211045 | T:sphincs256 |  | 42091153 | 42133557 | 42182169 | T:luov4849242 |  | 47720931 | 47758979 | 47845444 | picnic3l5 |  | 62243709 | 62303054 | 62345351 | T:sphincsf256harakasimple |  | 74011351 | 74107120 | 74213015 | T:sphincsf256harakarobust |  | 74500640 | 74563089 | 75097084 | T:rainbow3ccompres683248 |  | 80975280? | 96807274? | 113301591? | T:bluegemss128v2 |  | 100938460 | 101065216 | 101212759 | T:sphincsf128shake256simple |  | 118916543 | 118952374 | 119103267 | T:picnic2l1fs |  | 121205405 | 121748392 | 122393283 | T:luov6468330 |  | 105596845? | 126173540? | 147409865? | T:bluegemss128 |  | 133043272 | 133399315 | 133660941 | T:sphincsf192shake256simple |  | 141469666 | 141590500 | 141690183 | T:pqrsa15 |  | 168730237 | 169119173 | 169540315 | T:sphincsf128shake256robust |  | 178542576 | 179065803 | 179934369 | T:rainbow5ccompres963664 |  | 230350822 | 230734074 | 231185041 | T:sphincsf192shake256robust |  | 235569755 | 236115455 | 236706200 | T:luov8086399 |  | 208476471? | 250265396? | 292152262? | T:bluegemss192v2 |  | 237833607? | 285680647? | 379683548? | T:bluegemss192 |  | 291381611 | 291770585 | 292348417 | T:sphincsf256shake256simple |  | 349450214 | 349702351 | 350056210 | T:picnic2l3fs |  | 359755438 | 359952513 | 360154915 | T:sphincss128harakasimple |  | 333153434? | 398476994? | 465173401? | T:bluegemss256v2 |  | 427693119 | 427993603 | 428318624 | T:sphincss128harakarobust |  | 390647399? | 468153037? | 547634524? | T:bluegemss256 |  | 500838447 | 502094484 | 503688724 | T:sphincsf256shake256robust |  | 509922531 | 510805929 | 511931603 | T:sphincss256harakasimple |  | 508027134? | 611177059? | 813885026? | T:gemss128v2 |  | 615446346 | 615754883 | 616090737 | T:sphincss256harakarobust |  | 736484709 | 736707217 | 737111535 | T:picnic2l5fs |  | 629201067? | 752106107? | 892409172? | T:gemss128 |  | 789928730 | 790250734 | 790786878 | T:sphincss192harakasimple |  | 967272198 | 968369198 | 968936296 | T:sphincss192harakarobust |  | 1408240036? | 1423346045? | 1991329957? | T:gemss192v2 |  | 1561231083 | 1564076615 | 1568194598 | T:sphincss128shake256simple |  | 1636557936? | 1965747501? | 2308913744? | T:gemss192 |  | 2421156280 | 2442285164 | 2443583319 | T:sphincss256shake256simple |  | 2534721527 | 2537589962 | 2538050670 | T:sphincss128shake256robust |  | 2385992700? | 2865356787? | 3369483417? | T:gemss256v2 |  | 3301241204 | 3313340403 | 3319529244 | T:sphincss192shake256simple |  | 3004922788? | 3604399111? | 4206492958? | T:gemss256 |  | 4021041355 | 4025278382 | 4028467496 | T:sphincss256shake256robust |  | 5495679647 | 5502840940 | 5509213749 | T:sphincss192shake256robust |  | 
| Cycles to verify 59 bytes | 
|---|
 | 25% | 50% | 75% | system | 
|---|
 | 10168 | 10274 | 10446 | T:rainbowbinary256181212 |  | 18737 | 19320 | 19629 | T:rainbowbinary16242020 |  | 27362 | 29131 | 30591 | T:rainbow1aclassic363232 |  | 31227 | 31591 | 31899 | T:lattisigns512 |  | 51000 | 51282 | 51781 | dilithium2aes |  | 58448 | 59883 | 61078 | T:gravitysphincss |  | 71333 | 71594 | 72468 | dilithium3aes |  | 76932 | 77608 | 78556 | T:falcon512tree |  | 82484 | 82980 | 83819 | T:qtesla1 |  | 83929 | 84118 | 84457 | dilithium2 |  | 90532 | 91972 | 93743 | T:falcon512dyn |  | 90586 | 95556 | 99457 | T:sflashv2 |  | 99235 | 100008 | 104653 | T:luov863256pc |  | 101776 | 102103 | 103734 | dilithium5aes |  | 131591 | 133372 | 135725 | T:rainbow3cclassic683248 |  | 136936 | 137220 | 137494 | dilithium3 |  | 154171 | 155222 | 156301 | T:falcon1024tree |  | 168293 | 169209 | 170436 | T:qtesla3f |  | 168443 | 169212 | 170524 | ed25519 |  | 168865 | 170008 | 172037 | T:qtesla3s |  | 181731 | 183670 | 186163 | T:falcon1024dyn |  | 215548 | 216023 | 216584 | dilithium5 |  | 246374 | 248826 | 254748 | T:gravitysphincsm |  | 238436 | 249539 | 260801 | T:gemss128 |  | 244503 | 252887 | 264403 | T:bluegemss128 |  | 252664 | 264881 | 275632 | T:gemss128v2 |  | 259181 | 266134 | 270255 | T:redgemss128 |  | 259232 | 268278 | 274258 | T:bluegemss128v2 |  | 268980? | 270833? | 381787? | T:pass769 |  | 259641 | 271816 | 280569 | T:redgemss128v2 |  | 273731 | 276675 | 281436 | T:rainbow5cclassic963664 |  | 275129 | 288355 | 292491 | T:luov890351pc |  | 309855? | 314381? | 443309? | T:pass863 |  | 334266 | 340359 | 344921 | T:gravitysphincsl |  | 375651 | 378909 | 384670 | T:luov8117404pc |  | 379460 | 381611 | 384282 | T:edons128k08n72nu8l4mu3 |  | 388937 | 390676 | 391812 | T:qtesla1p |  | 402709 | 411018 | 422561 | T:sphincss128harakasimple |  | 509499 | 511342 | 513470 | T:ed448goldilocks |  | 537019 | 550711 | 564921 | T:gemss192 |  | 539298 | 555243 | 568516 | T:bluegemss192 |  | 544086 | 555887 | 571090 | T:redgemss192 |  | 578177 | 592242 | 602052 | T:gemss192v2 |  | 582035 | 592328 | 603605 | T:bluegemss192v2 |  | 583018 | 592493 | 605793 | T:sphincss128harakarobust |  | 591186 | 604127 | 616365 | T:redgemss192v2 |  | 624866 | 634213 | 641728 | T:sphincss192harakasimple |  | 638852 | 642994 | 645569 | T:edons128ref |  | 849342 | 867678 | 878071 | T:sphincss256harakasimple |  | 957496 | 971473 | 987269 | T:sphincsf128harakasimple |  | 973680 | 983283 | 989067 | T:sphincss192harakarobust |  | 1009165 | 1021655 | 1034349 | T:donald2048 |  | 1124696 | 1146580 | 1170723 | T:bluegemss256 |  | 1128601 | 1151640 | 1185169 | T:gemss256v2 |  | 1145085 | 1173405 | 1185765 | T:bluegemss256v2 |  | 1166005 | 1183532 | 1203910 | T:gemss256 |  | 1171677 | 1197522 | 1224546 | T:redgemss256v2 |  | 1192890 | 1197896 | 1205396 | T:sphincs256 |  | 1166927 | 1207728 | 1238310 | T:redgemss256 |  | 1316476 | 1333109 | 1351651 | T:sphincss256harakarobust |  | 1365814 | 1376708 | 1397917 | T:sphincsf128harakarobust |  | 1490799 | 1510330 | 1526817 | T:sphincsf192harakasimple |  | 1642610 | 1670088 | 1682282 | T:sphincsf256harakasimple |  | 1923703 | 1934582 | 1941558 | T:qtesla3p |  | 2296246 | 2299984 | 2320466 | picnicl1full |  | 2442295 | 2460832 | 2480086 | T:sphincsf192harakarobust |  | 2536595 | 2552856 | 2579751 | T:sphincsf256harakarobust |  | 2693610 | 2712046 | 2729784 | picnicl1fs |  | 2750403 | 2766566 | 2773809 | T:mqdss48 |  | 2852209 | 2856920 | 2864085 | T:luov863256 |  | 3075670 | 3159316 | 3213003 | T:sphincss128shake256simple |  | 3578491 | 3583547 | 3628499 | picnicl1ur |  | 4528022 | 4537629 | 4547359 | picnicl3full |  | 4580089 | 4669430 | 4791982 | T:sphincss192shake256simple |  | 5950669 | 6067862 | 6248230 | T:sphincss128shake256robust |  | 5972422 | 6070510 | 6236459 | T:sphincss256shake256simple |  | 6499483 | 6515037 | 6522294 | picnicl3fs |  | 6970565 | 7009464 | 7056651 | T:mqdss64 |  | 7599934 | 7630714 | 7644092 | picnicl5full |  | 7535824 | 7644529 | 7852974 | T:sphincsf128shake256simple |  | 8800064 | 8809207 | 8821755 | picnicl3ur |  | 8966974 | 9027508 | 9201958 | T:sphincss192shake256robust |  | 9756209 | 9768485 | 9804946 | T:rainbow1acompres363232 |  | 9839847 | 9867573 | 9877153 | T:rainbow1acyclicc363232 |  | 10075713 | 10083385 | 10101688 | T:luov890351 |  | 10608927 | 10630222 | 10648897 | picnic3l1 |  | 11216777 | 11249234 | 11598067 | picnicl5fs |  | 11596596 | 11804743 | 12018730 | T:sphincss256shake256robust |  | 12032853 | 12200744 | 12346056 | T:sphincsf192shake256simple |  | 12171675 | 12297443 | 12439584 | T:sphincsf256shake256simple |  | 14437680 | 14748567 | 15070602 | T:sphincsf128shake256robust |  | 14946603 | 14984495 | 15014108 | picnicl5ur |  | 17267582 | 17280362 | 17351704 | T:luov8117404 |  | 17895379 | 17912571 | 17938842 | T:pqrsa15 |  | 22640248 | 22675394 | 22704243 | picnic3l3 |  | 23044145 | 23421290 | 23720514 | T:sphincsf192shake256robust |  | 23763940 | 24096033 | 24352484 | T:sphincsf256shake256robust |  | 31074097 | 31100438 | 31242915 | T:luov4849242 |  | 36853683 | 36934604 | 37007472 | picnic3l5 |  | 48078833 | 48120399 | 48177145 | T:picnic2l1fs |  | 59262254 | 59301517 | 59812005 | T:rainbow3ccompres683248 |  | 59777413 | 60878685 | 61180556 | T:rainbow3ccyclicc683248 |  | 76327465 | 76550653 | 76763661 | T:luov6468330 |  | 108159740 | 108241715 | 108359132 | T:picnic2l3fs |  | 131066477 | 131421101 | 132484702 | T:rainbow5ccyclicc963664 |  | 131128930 | 131926883 | 134837453 | T:rainbow5ccompres963664 |  | 146976693 | 147249153 | 147568293 | T:luov8086399 |  | 189963352 | 190108938 | 190273731 | T:picnic2l5fs |  | 
 |  |