| Measurements of public-key signature systems on one machine: amd64; Zen 3 (a50f00); 2021 AMD Ryzen 5 5560U; 6 x 4062MHz; beelink, supercop-20221122
[Page version: 20251028 08:35:44] 
eBATS
(ECRYPT Benchmarking
of Asymmetric Systems)
is a project
to measure the performance of public-key systems.
This page presents benchmark results collected in eBATS
for public-key signature systems:
 
Time (cycles) to generate a key pair:
a secret key and a corresponding public key.
Time to sign a short message (59 bytes).
Time to open a signed short message,
i.e., to verify a (larger) signed message and recover the original short message.
Space (bytes) for a secret key.
Space for a public key.
Space for a signature on a 0-byte message.
Space for a signature on a 23-byte message:
i.e.,
the signed-message length minus 23 bytes.
Space for a signature on a long message:
i.e.,
the signed-message length minus the message length.
 
For signature systems that support "message recovery",
the space for a signature on a long message
is shorter than the space for a signature on a short message.
 
Each table row lists
the first quartile of many speed measurements,
the median of many speed measurements,
the third quartile of many speed measurements, and
the name of the primitive.
Measurements with large variance are indicated in red with question marks.
The symbol
T:
(starting with supercop-20200816)
means that the SUPERCOP database
at the time of benchmarking did not list constant time
as a goal for this implementation.
The symbol
T!!!
means that constant time was listed as a goal for this implementation,
but that the implementation failed TIMECOP.
(TIMECOP failures are not necessarily security issues;
they can sometimes be resolved by, e.g., declaring that a rejection-sampling condition is safe to declassify.)
 
There is a
separate page
with more information about each signature system and each implementation.
Designers and implementors
interested in submitting new signature systems
and new implementations of existing signature systems
should read the call for submissions.
 
 Test results Graphs:
(pkcycles,pkbytes)
(smcycles,sbytes)
(mcycles,pkbytes)
(mcycles,sbytes)
(pkbytes,sbytes)
 NISTPQC graphs:
(pkcycles,pkbytes)
(smcycles,sbytes)
(mcycles,pkbytes)
(mcycles,sbytes)
(pkbytes,sbytes)
 Measurement failures: ntrumls401x, ntrumls439x, ntrumls593x, ntrumls743x, qtesla128, qtesla192, qtesla256 
| 
| 
| Cycles to generate a key pair | 
|---|
 | 25% | 50% | 75% | system | 
|---|
 | 2420 | 2428 | 2484 | picnicl1full |  | 2489 | 2516 | 2875 | picnic3l1 |  | 3282 | 3294 | 3332 | picnicl3full |  | 3294 | 3302 | 3318 | picnic3l3 |  | 3975 | 3982 | 4006 | picnicl1ur |  | 4016 | 4024 | 4046 | picnicl1fs |  | 4008 | 4125 | 4348 | T:picnic2l1fs |  | 4170 | 4208 | 4241 | picnicl5full |  | 4227 | 4246 | 4369 | picnic3l5 |  | 6365 | 6453 | 6761 | T:picnic2l3fs |  | 6777 | 6808 | 6851 | picnicl3fs |  | 6757 | 6855 | 7791 | picnicl3ur |  | 8575 | 8698 | 9868 | T:picnic2l5fs |  | 8646 | 8704 | 8847 | picnicl5ur |  | 9078 | 9186 | 9498 | picnicl5fs |  | 17330 | 17414 | 17582 | T:lattisigns512 |  | 44480 | 44636 | 44887 | ed25519 |  | 51855 | 52044 | 52440 | dilithium2aes |  | 81195 | 81552 | 82448 | dilithium2 |  | 82152 | 82504 | 83139 | dilithium3aes |  | 124312 | 124979 | 125483 | dilithium5aes |  | 144400 | 144809 | 145362 | dilithium3 |  | 156991 | 157485 | 158025 | T:ed448goldilocks |  | 178138 | 179854 | 181319 | T:pass769 |  | 204270 | 206080 | 207220 | T:pass863 |  | 220348 | 220723 | 222039 | dilithium5 |  | 547718 | 548435 | 551747 | T:sphincsf128harakasimple |  | 641422 | 643303 | 644592 | T:mqdss48 |  | 662056 | 663275 | 667439 | T:sphincsf128harakarobust |  | 714876 | 719576 | 724235 | T:edons128k08n72nu8l4mu3 |  | 820676 | 823284 | 824656 | T:sphincsf192harakasimple |  | 831814 | 840500 | 853413 | T:donald2048 |  | 993341 | 995531 | 998503 | T:sphincsf192harakarobust |  | 1003028? | 1059020? | 1683356? | T:qtesla1 |  | 1492769 | 1495371 | 1497538 | T:mqdss64 |  | 2008200 | 2014609 | 2022772 | T:sphincsf256harakasimple |  | 2159003 | 2164219 | 2175124 | T:edons128ref |  | 2585485 | 2586191 | 2591449 | T:sphincsf256harakarobust |  | 2628511 | 2635670 | 2649377 | T:sphincs256 |  | 2065260? | 3053380? | 4042619? | T:qtesla3f |  | 4053817 | 4055695 | 4091710 | T:luov863256 |  | 4294050 | 4299414 | 4304158 | T:sphincsf128shake256simple |  | 3111052? | 5107249? | 7123021? | T:qtesla3s |  | 4625403? | 5307172? | 6507252? | T:qtesla1p |  | 6338953 | 6344498 | 6348559 | T:luov863256pc |  | 6357714 | 6371488 | 6382221 | T:sphincsf192shake256simple |  | 7743769 | 7751660 | 7759270 | T:sphincsf128shake256robust |  | 7825123 | 7838416 | 7854511 | T:rainbowbinary256181212 |  | 11928577 | 11934399 | 11950287 | T:sphincsf192shake256robust |  | 12327729 | 12401972 | 12680800 | T:rainbow1aclassic363232 |  | 14128727 | 14198151 | 14533242 | T:rainbow1acompres363232 |  | 15002414 | 15783930 | 17428057 | T:falcon512dyn |  | 15124760 | 16037510 | 17117884 | T:falcon512tree |  | 16225245 | 16298734 | 16478416 | T:luov890351 |  | 17065143 | 17101383 | 17135392 | T:sphincsf256shake256simple |  | 18450918 | 18463509 | 18526566 | T:sphincss128harakasimple |  | 19078077 | 19152148 | 19384510 | T:rainbow1acyclicc363232 |  | 19834215 | 19916918 | 20031583 | T:luov4849242 |  | 20485678 | 20505650 | 20527642 | T:sphincss128harakarobust |  | 20123954? | 23834067? | 29439475? | T:qtesla3p |  | 24235916 | 24268622 | 24355923 | T:luov890351pc |  | 24494317 | 24595446 | 24663506 | T:sphincss192harakasimple |  | 29987290 | 30028065 | 30107422 | T:sphincss192harakarobust |  | 30328575 | 30356714 | 30709884 | T:luov8117404 |  | 31477967 | 31597512 | 31642242 | T:sphincsf256shake256robust |  | 34213515 | 34284245 | 34348389 | T:sphincss256harakasimple |  | 37210055 | 37252466 | 37295311 | T:rainbowbinary16242020 |  | 41112686 | 41126772 | 41146073 | T:sphincss256harakarobust |  | 45149795 | 45254350 | 45374678 | T:luov8117404pc |  | 47671451 | 49063332 | 52113580 | T:falcon1024dyn |  | 47928164 | 49352054 | 50577731 | T:falcon1024tree |  | 49590761 | 49615478 | 49700790 | T:gemss128 |  | 50013196 | 50078740 | 50136964 | T:bluegemss128 |  | 51593735 | 51671943 | 51759486 | T:redgemss128 |  | 55492644 | 55602202 | 55668541 | T:gemss128v2 |  | 56754113 | 56803312 | 56851365 | T:bluegemss128v2 |  | 58801803 | 58885438 | 59144185 | T:redgemss128v2 |  | 59685734 | 59806111 | 59916281 | T:luov6468330 |  | 76835316 | 77815225 | 80087940 | T:rainbow3cclassic683248 |  | 80766776 | 80915983 | 83983307 | T:rainbow3ccompres683248 |  | 84796069 | 86297423 | 86857613 | T:rainbow3ccyclicc683248 |  | 117803952 | 117977494 | 118190061 | T:luov8086399 |  | 137859904 | 138091546 | 138737940 | T:sphincss128shake256simple |  | 153941329 | 153995900 | 154106995 | T:sflashv2 |  | 203074901 | 203400301 | 203579680 | T:sphincss192shake256simple |  | 221116352 | 221287694 | 221502933 | T:redgemss192 |  | 227221212 | 227297375 | 227425525 | T:gemss192 |  | 227335798 | 227861756 | 228285665 | T:bluegemss192 |  | 244875453 | 245044390 | 245299990 | T:redgemss192v2 |  | 246183755 | 246425510 | 246481835 | T:gemss192v2 |  | 249205436 | 249334031 | 250630801 | T:bluegemss192v2 |  | 250683915 | 250849566 | 253854723 | T:sphincss128shake256robust |  | 261711354 | 262261683 | 268839673 | T:rainbow5cclassic963664 |  | 265156944 | 265961981 | 266679448 | T:rainbow5ccyclicc963664 |  | 268329251 | 269322510 | 273272651 | T:rainbow5ccompres963664 |  | 270134300 | 270437435 | 272883968 | T:sphincss256shake256simple |  | 380147667 | 380360268 | 380423427 | T:sphincss192shake256robust |  | 504362596 | 505294758 | 505982786 | T:sphincss256shake256robust |  | 634167332 | 636638815 | 638544368 | T:redgemss256 |  | 652078105 | 653282536 | 655983679 | T:bluegemss256 |  | 656801612 | 657868211 | 667484973 | T:gemss256 |  | 681602390 | 683829809 | 685582227 | T:redgemss256v2 |  | 680861225 | 687248719 | 697034407 | T:gemss256v2 |  | 688634372 | 691874456 | 696374938 | T:bluegemss256v2 |  | 898037386 | 898229860 | 898427142 | T:gravitysphincss |  | 3233631765 | 3300498267 | 3376274043 | T:pqrsa15 |  | 14366756107 | 14368503297 | 14370816885 | T:gravitysphincsl |  | 28749523072 | 28752468646 | 28754362381 | T:gravitysphincsm |  | 
| Cycles to sign 59 bytes | 
|---|
 | 25% | 50% | 75% | system | 
|---|
 | 11933 | 12279 | 12543 | T:rainbowbinary256181212 |  | 24244 | 24817 | 25543 | T:rainbowbinary16242020 |  | 48809 | 48860 | 48900 | ed25519 |  | 58484 | 63556 | 68253 | T:rainbow1aclassic363232 |  | 89056 | 89308 | 89793 | T:sflashv2 |  | 90344? | 117244? | 155247? | dilithium2aes |  | 157550 | 159370 | 163783 | T:rainbow1acyclicc363232 |  | 162745 | 163142 | 163364 | T:ed448goldilocks |  | 94024? | 175478? | 419291? | T:lattisigns512 |  | 123436? | 181204? | 226668? | dilithium3aes |  | 128571? | 190504? | 290708? | dilithium2 |  | 176682? | 228077? | 392486? | dilithium5aes |  | 271481 | 272869 | 275618 | T:luov863256pc |  | 155136? | 279841? | 586376? | T:qtesla1 |  | 199206? | 293218? | 375021? | dilithium3 |  | 308167 | 309699 | 311277 | T:rainbow3cclassic683248 |  | 287565? | 356445? | 571383? | dilithium5 |  | 364168 | 369807 | 372782 | T:falcon512tree |  | 310049? | 419028? | 798415? | T:qtesla3f |  | 421032 | 432898 | 441568 | T:rainbow3ccyclicc683248 |  | 223077? | 440542? | 662935? | T:pass769 |  | 258322? | 500254? | 752810? | T:pass863 |  | 392587? | 604706? | 995061? | T:qtesla1p |  | 660831 | 663838 | 667678 | T:falcon512dyn |  | 744577 | 749986 | 755963 | T:falcon1024tree |  | 756543 | 762477 | 768622 | T:luov890351pc |  | 819545 | 823050 | 828443 | T:rainbow5cclassic963664 |  | 836103 | 843774 | 849294 | T:donald2048 |  | 422788? | 915276? | 1396862? | T:qtesla3s |  | 1004436 | 1029544 | 1047159 | T:rainbow5ccyclicc963664 |  | 1047868 | 1062035 | 1069388 | T:edons128k08n72nu8l4mu3 |  | 1129482 | 1133627 | 1137377 | T:luov8117404pc |  | 1326689 | 1333569 | 1340071 | T:falcon1024dyn |  | 2489825 | 2501320 | 2513396 | T:edons128ref |  | 1879271? | 2604827? | 4872805? | T:qtesla3p |  | 3389594 | 3391561 | 3414217 | picnicl1full |  | 3610724 | 3612259 | 3613543 | T:luov863256 |  | 3156846? | 3734521? | 4673466? | T:redgemss128 |  | 3966245 | 3969876 | 3973215 | T:mqdss48 |  | 4046014 | 4056244 | 4057683 | picnicl1fs |  | 3598417? | 4206319? | 5274476? | T:redgemss128v2 |  | 5411162 | 5413842 | 5416592 | picnicl1ur |  | 6501311 | 6507210 | 6513677 | picnicl3full |  | 6873887 | 6886539 | 6899519 | T:gravitysphincss |  | 9522999 | 9548854 | 9577041 | T:mqdss64 |  | 9543962 | 9573525 | 9717320 | picnicl3fs |  | 8593159? | 9967098? | 11795889? | T:redgemss192v2 |  | 8661313? | 10159898? | 11605322? | T:redgemss192 |  | 10590545 | 10602418 | 10612018 | picnicl5full |  | 11107104 | 11224595 | 11534518 | T:rainbow1acompres363232 |  | 11673395 | 11678605 | 11683267 | T:luov890351 |  | 12922297 | 12939272 | 12985198 | T:gravitysphincsm |  | 12977429 | 12980460 | 12999338 | picnicl3ur |  | 15338252 | 15383145 | 15872953 | T:gravitysphincsl |  | 16071059 | 16236886 | 16249836 | picnicl5fs |  | 16450451 | 16465965 | 16477717 | picnic3l1 |  | 14418231? | 16598311? | 19578048? | T:redgemss256v2 |  | 15006279? | 17628223? | 23330976? | T:redgemss256 |  | 19882744 | 19918466 | 19958275 | T:sphincsf128harakasimple |  | 20199865 | 20210593 | 20686605 | T:luov8117404 |  | 20927037 | 20954911 | 20981653 | picnicl5ur |  | 24117295 | 24154166 | 24213112 | T:sphincsf192harakasimple |  | 24441891 | 24486821 | 24544104 | T:sphincsf128harakarobust |  | 30354485 | 30380620 | 30412902 | T:sphincsf192harakarobust |  | 35106285 | 35138214 | 35193089 | picnic3l3 |  | 40126453 | 40319556 | 40546779 | T:luov4849242 |  | 46185813 | 46251595 | 46416616 | T:sphincs256 |  | 51786823 | 51864050 | 51945285 | T:sphincsf256harakasimple |  | 59457316 | 59546996 | 59582766 | picnic3l5 |  | 65647574 | 65860605 | 66409238 | T:rainbow3ccompres683248 |  | 67972595 | 68048911 | 68100731 | T:sphincsf256harakarobust |  | 114773063 | 114848095 | 115337549 | T:luov6468330 |  | 116582284 | 116631994 | 116696695 | T:pqrsa15 |  | 120749585 | 120846956 | 121566121 | T:picnic2l1fs |  | 114017163? | 136696208? | 159730899? | T:bluegemss128 |  | 139480476 | 139637967 | 139749165 | T:sphincsf128shake256simple |  | 120269992? | 162065030? | 185973835? | T:bluegemss128v2 |  | 167708509 | 168093357 | 168514503 | T:rainbow5ccompres963664 |  | 178198384 | 178404984 | 178621847 | T:sphincsf192shake256simple |  | 233426522 | 233660642 | 234891260 | T:luov8086399 |  | 240436403 | 240702571 | 241048499 | T:sphincsf128shake256robust |  | 317948354 | 318121603 | 318229437 | T:picnic2l3fs |  | 327234103 | 327394134 | 327609717 | T:sphincsf192shake256robust |  | 351415177 | 351893469 | 352229041 | T:sphincss128harakasimple |  | 326477136? | 391491873? | 521685818? | T:bluegemss192 |  | 283815440? | 396250278? | 453434845? | T:bluegemss192v2 |  | 399505904 | 399911922 | 400255017 | T:sphincsf256shake256simple |  | 406567838 | 406823042 | 407090623 | T:sphincss128harakarobust |  | 479581545 | 480282771 | 480853967 | T:sphincss256harakasimple |  | 590951857 | 591188170 | 591933236 | T:sphincss256harakarobust |  | 451781852? | 630160996? | 658242679? | T:bluegemss256v2 |  | 649808730 | 651381820 | 652239102 | T:picnic2l5fs |  | 570916546? | 712572601? | 994141857? | T:gemss128v2 |  | 715344142 | 715790751 | 716549560 | T:sphincsf256shake256robust |  | 715923699 | 716679642 | 717946083 | T:sphincss192harakasimple |  | 567173633? | 792550024? | 794217681? | T:bluegemss256 |  | 703094154? | 848813631? | 1123578382? | T:gemss128 |  | 963248049 | 964816219 | 965891450 | T:sphincss192harakarobust |  | 2216416050 | 2218170646 | 2218986270 | T:sphincss128shake256simple |  | 1890627543? | 2272249394? | 2656695733? | T:gemss192v2 |  | 2226964651? | 2666547038? | 3112269699? | T:gemss192 |  | 3307642592 | 3327057913 | 3360340411 | T:sphincss256shake256simple |  | 3763870460 | 3768577677 | 3777572454 | T:sphincss128shake256robust |  | 3230026860? | 3876602145? | 4521847483? | T:gemss256v2 |  | 4609180965 | 4612847481 | 4618647892 | T:sphincss192shake256simple |  | 4005186822? | 4808923916? | 6404755903? | T:gemss256 |  | 5909289153 | 5912768778 | 5915357167 | T:sphincss256shake256robust |  | 7965278121 | 7968348258 | 7971196226 | T:sphincss192shake256robust |  | 
| Cycles to verify 59 bytes | 
|---|
 | 25% | 50% | 75% | system | 
|---|
 | 9266 | 9565 | 9993 | T:rainbowbinary256181212 |  | 16892 | 17128 | 17608 | T:rainbowbinary16242020 |  | 24591 | 26147 | 28887 | T:rainbow1aclassic363232 |  | 28641 | 28954 | 29338 | T:lattisigns512 |  | 53598 | 53811 | 53990 | dilithium2aes |  | 59192 | 60617 | 63123 | T:gravitysphincss |  | 77827 | 78218 | 78674 | T:qtesla1 |  | 77447 | 78223 | 78957 | T:falcon512tree |  | 78362 | 78708 | 79127 | dilithium3aes |  | 80530 | 80681 | 80817 | dilithium2 |  | 83216 | 84526 | 85395 | T:falcon512dyn |  | 99682 | 99819 | 100934 | T:sflashv2 |  | 106378 | 107439 | 108897 | T:luov863256pc |  | 118129 | 118344 | 118695 | dilithium5aes |  | 132439 | 132626 | 132749 | dilithium3 |  | 141907 | 142651 | 143628 | T:falcon1024tree |  | 157536 | 158112 | 159017 | T:qtesla3f |  | 159032 | 159991 | 160847 | T:qtesla3s |  | 160696 | 161888 | 163032 | ed25519 |  | 161308 | 162947 | 165109 | T:rainbow3cclassic683248 |  | 168506 | 169276 | 169943 | T:falcon1024dyn |  | 208337 | 208798 | 209026 | dilithium5 |  | 238957 | 243411 | 249960 | T:redgemss128 |  | 242474 | 253697 | 261087 | T:redgemss128v2 |  | 257025 | 261169 | 269651 | T:gravitysphincsm |  | 270573 | 272557 | 274791 | T:pass769 |  | 307464 | 310299 | 312049 | T:pass863 |  | 310558 | 324927 | 341796 | T:gemss128v2 |  | 298974 | 325179 | 339048 | T:bluegemss128v2 |  | 305485 | 337570 | 362250 | T:bluegemss128 |  | 334629 | 339914 | 347277 | T:luov890351pc |  | 322439 | 345315 | 375836 | T:gemss128 |  | 350096 | 354845 | 359196 | T:gravitysphincsl |  | 368269 | 369330 | 371366 | T:qtesla1p |  | 369346 | 378887 | 383031 | T:edons128k08n72nu8l4mu3 |  | 379098 | 381132 | 387340 | T:rainbow5cclassic963664 |  | 397007 | 406362 | 413941 | T:sphincss128harakasimple |  | 460186 | 469444 | 476565 | T:luov8117404pc |  | 560115 | 572549 | 580169 | T:sphincss192harakasimple |  | 572639 | 574551 | 575802 | T:ed448goldilocks |  | 570925 | 583333 | 596418 | T:sphincss128harakarobust |  | 579452 | 592382 | 602555 | T:redgemss192 |  | 591801 | 598378 | 607023 | T:edons128ref |  | 615748 | 628844 | 643045 | T:redgemss192v2 |  | 785390 | 798845 | 810307 | T:sphincss256harakasimple |  | 638787? | 839291? | 863452? | T:bluegemss192v2 |  | 838923 | 865407 | 1005315 | T:gemss192v2 |  | 905567 | 914592 | 926878 | T:sphincsf128harakasimple |  | 927455 | 950348 | 956537 | T:sphincss192harakarobust |  | 969164 | 993583 | 1015728 | T:gemss192 |  | 982031 | 994172 | 1000637 | T:donald2048 |  | 691627? | 1011472? | 1044974? | T:bluegemss192 |  | 1184289 | 1213845 | 1276964 | T:redgemss256 |  | 1206600 | 1222767 | 1263553 | T:redgemss256v2 |  | 1201207 | 1242066 | 1397844 | T:gemss256v2 |  | 1191029? | 1294873? | 2097259? | T:gemss256 |  | 1256918? | 1295218? | 2215646? | T:bluegemss256v2 |  | 1306300 | 1320154 | 1337050 | T:sphincss256harakarobust |  | 1348422 | 1358953 | 1382519 | T:sphincsf128harakarobust |  | 1384405 | 1394716 | 1409684 | T:sphincsf192harakasimple |  | 1522124 | 1536752 | 1552142 | T:sphincsf256harakasimple |  | 1256494? | 1586109? | 2393216? | T:bluegemss256 |  | 1608354 | 1620611 | 1632159 | T:sphincs256 |  | 1801693 | 1807962 | 1813359 | T:qtesla3p |  | 2282589 | 2299180 | 2324025 | T:sphincsf192harakarobust |  | 2396567 | 2427043 | 2464820 | T:sphincsf256harakarobust |  | 2479801 | 2487430 | 2506748 | T:mqdss48 |  | 2622518 | 2641556 | 2668546 | picnicl1full |  | 2997244 | 3001392 | 3002916 | T:luov863256 |  | 2989769 | 3090939 | 3164267 | T:sphincss128shake256simple |  | 3138432 | 3142229 | 3160965 | picnicl1fs |  | 4255648 | 4259868 | 4283299 | picnicl1ur |  | 4437619 | 4498712 | 4572264 | T:sphincss192shake256simple |  | 5134482 | 5137226 | 5141514 | picnicl3full |  | 5603660 | 5715254 | 5965127 | T:sphincss128shake256robust |  | 5858288 | 5956933 | 6092410 | T:sphincss256shake256simple |  | 6224764 | 6250909 | 6274502 | T:mqdss64 |  | 7336057 | 7354292 | 7359701 | picnicl3fs |  | 7252059 | 7433943 | 7519003 | T:sphincsf128shake256simple |  | 8354647 | 8384064 | 8390085 | picnicl5full |  | 8378864 | 8447801 | 8666518 | T:rainbow1acyclicc363232 |  | 8502969 | 8611837 | 8733441 | T:sphincss192shake256robust |  | 8746552 | 8915603 | 9040701 | T:rainbow1acompres363232 |  | 10250184 | 10273270 | 10648396 | picnicl3ur |  | 10518187 | 10538452 | 10542208 | T:luov890351 |  | 11371725 | 11663628 | 11879795 | T:sphincss256shake256robust |  | 11616738 | 11744655 | 11983661 | T:sphincsf192shake256simple |  | 11884848 | 12066761 | 12222506 | T:sphincsf256shake256simple |  | 12621145 | 12635341 | 12655688 | picnicl5fs |  | 13348214 | 13361668 | 13378940 | picnic3l1 |  | 13731751 | 13995119 | 14237580 | T:sphincsf128shake256robust |  | 16061651 | 16100686 | 16126525 | T:pqrsa15 |  | 16889713 | 16970612 | 17075255 | picnicl5ur |  | 18131442 | 18142106 | 18156166 | T:luov8117404 |  | 22202881 | 22420017 | 22640857 | T:sphincsf192shake256robust |  | 23062145 | 23289307 | 23521938 | T:sphincsf256shake256robust |  | 27055922 | 27083499 | 27103105 | T:luov4849242 |  | 28485459 | 28523879 | 28552389 | picnic3l3 |  | 46093383 | 46129084 | 46168371 | picnic3l5 |  | 51727260 | 52017225 | 53809415 | T:rainbow3ccyclicc683248 |  | 52425525 | 52916040 | 54133997 | T:rainbow3ccompres683248 |  | 63640627 | 63704418 | 63762607 | T:picnic2l1fs |  | 70142742 | 70237464 | 70366709 | T:luov6468330 |  | 115262969 | 116704351 | 120689989 | T:rainbow5ccompres963664 |  | 118297468 | 118657787 | 119230689 | T:rainbow5ccyclicc963664 |  | 129025467 | 129287553 | 131545661 | T:luov8086399 |  | 137445781 | 137515793 | 137620061 | T:picnic2l3fs |  | 236156243 | 236300735 | 236649753 | T:picnic2l5fs |  | 
 |  |