Measurements of key-encapsulation mechanisms on one machine: amd64; Skylake (506e3); 2015 Intel Core i5-6500T; 4 x 2500MHz; thinksky, supercop-20261018
[Page version: 20261107 07:58:52]
eBATS
(ECRYPT Benchmarking
of Asymmetric Systems)
is a project
to measure the performance of public-key systems.
This page presents benchmark results collected in eBATS
for key-encapsulation mechanisms:
- Time (cycles) to generate a key pair:
a secret key and a corresponding public key.
- Time for "encapsulation":
time to compute a ciphertext and corresponding session key, given a user's public key.
- Time for "decapsulation":
time to compute the session key from the ciphertext, given the user's secret key.
- Space (bytes) for a secret key.
- Space for a public key.
- Space for a ciphertext.
- Space for a session key.
Each table row lists
the first quartile of many speed measurements (or StQ1 starting with supercop-20260214),
the median of many speed measurements (or StQ2 starting with supercop-20260214),
the third quartile of many speed measurements (or StQ3 starting with supercop-20260214), and
the name of the primitive.
Measurements with large interquartile range (or stabilized interquartile range) are indicated in red with question marks.
The symbol
C:
means that the current SUPERCOP database does not list IND-CCA2 security
as a goal for this key-encapsulation mechanism.
The symbol
T:
(starting with supercop-20200816)
means that the SUPERCOP database
at the time of benchmarking did not list constant time
as a goal for this implementation.
The symbol
T!!!
means that constant time was listed as a goal for this implementation,
but that the implementation failed TIMECOP.
(TIMECOP failures are not necessarily security issues;
they can sometimes be resolved by, e.g., declaring that a rejection-sampling condition is safe to declassify.)
There is a
separate page
with more information about each key-encapsulation mechanism and each implementation.
Designers and implementors
interested in submitting new key-encapsulation mechanisms
and new implementations of existing systems
should read the call for submissions.
Test results
Graphs:
(pkcycles,pkbytes)
(ccycles,cbytes)
(kcycles,cbytes)
(pkbytes,cbytes)
NISTPQC graphs:
(pkcycles,pkbytes)
(ccycles,cbytes)
(kcycles,cbytes)
(pkbytes,cbytes)
| Cycles to generate a key pair |
| 25% | 50% | 75% | system |
| 16899 | 17136 | 17589 | kyber90s512 |
| 19692 | 19795 | 23317 | ntruplus576 |
| 20462 | 20501 | 20628 | ntruplus768 |
| 21715 | 21755 | 21834 | ntruplus864 |
| 22374 | 22484 | 22699 | mlkem512 |
| 22489 | 22685 | 23265 | kyber512 |
| 25215 | 25499 | 26134 | kyber90s768 |
| 25461 | 25511 | 25651 | smaugt1v5 |
| 27020 | 27141 | 27336 | T: C:nhcompact512cca |
| 30038? | 33492? | 39169? | ntruplus1152 |
| 33605 | 33889 | 34688 | T: lac128 |
| 34942 | 34977 | 35260 | T: lightsaber2 |
| 35266 | 35663 | 36866 | kyber90s1024 |
| 36900 | 36992 | 37141 | smaugt1 |
| 37417 | 37729 | 37856 | timer |
| 37725 | 38268 | 38509 | ntrulpr653 |
| 38624 | 38767 | 39218 | mlkem768 |
| 38612 | 38976 | 39106 | T: ntrulpr4591761 |
| 39103 | 39311 | 39613 | T: C:nhcompact768cca |
| 39253 | 39386 | 40083 | ntrulpr761 |
| 39163 | 40031 | 41519 | kyber768 |
| 40454 | 40513 | 40601 | threebears624r2cca |
| 40611 | 40665 | 40751 | C:threebears624r2cpa |
| 42406 | 42469 | 42569 | C:threebears624r2cpax |
| 43548 | 43608 | 43699 | threebears624r2ccax |
| 45877 | 46145 | 46584 | T!!!newhope512cca |
| 47041 | 47118 | 47423 | smaugt3v5 |
| 46734 | 47149 | 47648 | T: C:r5nd1kem0d |
| 49638 | 49956 | 50212 | ntrulpr857 |
| 50779 | 50929 | 51224 | T: C:nhcompact1024cca |
| 51882 | 52098 | 52850 | ntrulpr953 |
| 52987 | 53661 | 53913 | ntrulpr1013 |
| 53814 | 54026 | 54497 | mlkem1024 |
| 54085 | 54639 | 55569 | kyber1024 |
| 56285 | 56589 | 56971 | smaugt3 |
| 63212 | 63276 | 63524 | T: saber2 |
| 63855 | 64659 | 65402 | T: C:r5nd1kem5d |
| 65850 | 66607 | 68133 | T: C:r5nd0kem2iot |
| 66867 | 67022 | 67266 | smaugt5v5 |
| 66585 | 67325 | 68430 | T: C:r5nd1kem4longkey |
| 68715 | 68947 | 69113 | ntrulpr1277 |
| 73911 | 74536 | 75073 | timerv5 |
| 76007 | 76302 | 77036 | smaugt5 |
| 80945 | 81053 | 81232 | threebears936r2cca |
| 81293 | 81551 | 82409 | T: lac256 |
| 82548 | 82709 | 83285 | T: hqc128round4 |
| 85078 | 85149 | 85284 | C:threebears936r2cpa |
| 85325 | 85429 | 85615 | threebears936r2ccax |
| 87526 | 87871 | 88201 | T!!!newhope1024cca |
| 89009 | 89127 | 89349 | C:threebears936r2cpax |
| 89412 | 90069 | 92123 | T: lac192 |
| 98370 | 98509 | 98869 | T: firesaber2 |
| 103984 | 104956 | 106056 | T: C:r5nd3kem5d |
| 120955 | 121090 | 121309 | threebears1248r2cca |
| 127336 | 127452 | 127602 | C:threebears1248r2cpa |
| 127630 | 127845 | 128032 | threebears1248r2ccax |
| 130013 | 130130 | 130300 | C:threebears1248r2cpax |
| 155638 | 156956 | 159015 | T: C:r5nd3kem0d |
| 157426 | 157970 | 158772 | ntruhps2048509 |
| 175683 | 176389 | 177069 | T: C:hila5 |
| 182526 | 183196 | 183656 | T: saberx4 |
| 186708 | 187656 | 188881 | T: C:r5nd5kem0d |
| 189227 | 189628 | 190611 | T: hqc192round4 |
| 189588 | 191580 | 193253 | T: C:r5nd5kem5d |
| 244477 | 244857 | 245313 | T: kindi256342 |
| 258434 | 258949 | 260394 | ntruhrss701 |
| 261984 | 262720 | 263630 | T: kindi512222 |
| 275496 | 276850 | 282381 | ntruhps2048677 |
| 280843 | 287611 | 288415 | T: kindi512241 |
| 360296 | 362205 | 366778 | T: hqcrmrs128 |
| 387830 | 390213 | 394849 | T: C:r5n11kem0d |
| 389773 | 391301 | 392617 | ntruhps4096821 |
| 392560 | 393287 | 394058 | T: hqc256round4 |
| 404052 | 406487 | 420271 | T: hqc128 |
| 419178 | 422835 | 426040 | T: ntrukem443 |
| 431897 | 434586 | 449510 | T: hqc1281 |
| 538713 | 539446 | 540393 | T: kindi512321 |
| 593648 | 594988 | 599630 | T: C:bikel1 |
| 632582 | 639694 | 642680 | sntrup653 |
| 667240 | 669262 | 671125 | T: C:ledakemcpa14 |
| 693449 | 695140 | 697572 | T: lima2p1024cca |
| 718279 | 719945 | 724983 | sntrup761 |
| 722669 | 724346 | 732826 | T: kindi256522 |
| 728848 | 730026 | 741694 | T: hqcrmrs192 |
| 739812 | 753675 | 756545 | T: C:r5n13kem0d |
| 758109 | 760711 | 763244 | T: rqc128 |
| 782091 | 794853 | 814736 | T: hqc1921 |
| 814334 | 816538 | 818680 | T: C:ledakemcpa13 |
| 813238 | 822768 | 840607 | T: hqc192 |
| 836635 | 852138 | 866576 | T: C:edonk128k16n80nu4l6 |
| 856862 | 858625 | 879916 | sntrup4591761 |
| 841107 | 860856 | 861758 | T: titaniumccatoy |
| 852506 | 874234 | 886034 | T: hqc1922 |
| 944093 | 948336 | 952393 | T: ntrukem743 |
| 951160 | 952590 | 985585 | T: titaniumccalite |
| 953869 | 957123 | 960767 | T: C:rolloi128 |
| 1013608 | 1018181 | 1020042 | T: C:ledakemcpa12 |
| 1059015 | 1060758 | 1085154 | sntrup857 |
| 1096144 | 1097274 | 1098927 | T: frodokem640 |
| 1177902 | 1207636 | 1221008 | T: hqcrmrs256 |
| 1210676 | 1211799 | 1250868 | T: titaniumccastd |
| 1212216 | 1226832 | 1244488 | T: hqc2561 |
| 1272734 | 1280415 | 1300981 | sntrup953 |
| 1264848 | 1288122 | 1305686 | T: hqc2562 |
| 1298717 | 1301013 | 1303292 | T: C:rolloi192 |
| 1308372 | 1311708 | 1462553 | T: rqc192 |
| 1306698 | 1339519 | 1361638 | T: hqc256 |
| 1345180 | 1346785 | 1351325 | T: frodokem640aes |
| 1371267 | 1387100 | 1414666 | T: hqc2563 |
| 1405445 | 1408864 | 1414769 | T: lima2p2048cca |
| 1366157 | 1412479 | 1416089 | T: titaniumccamed |
| 1412197 | 1414980 | 1423478 | sntrup1013 |
| 1418850 | 1421903 | 1426207 | T: C:edonk128k16n80nu8l6 |
| 1448168 | 1456665 | 1468997 | T: C:ledakemcpa34 |
| 1460241 | 1468034 | 1472820 | T: limasp1018cca |
| 1529431 | 1537120 | 1545081 | T: titaniumccahi |
| 1578773 | 1600027 | 1619428 | T: C:edonk128k32n96nu4l4 |
| 1623060 | 1628113 | 1633713 | T: C:r5n15kem0d |
| 1636324 | 1638874 | 1659016 | T: C:bikel3 |
| 1735769 | 1738035 | 1741011 | T: C:rolloi256 |
| 1870790? | 1875222? | 2362493? | T: rqc256 |
| 1908592 | 1932768 | 1962587 | T: C:edonk192k32n128nu4l6 |
| 2036697 | 2071015 | 2072365 | T: titaniumccasuper |
| 2077465 | 2082126 | 2090018 | T: C:edonk128ref |
| 2172639 | 2177146 | 2203698 | T: C:ledakemcpa33 |
| 2184028 | 2206269 | 2217081 | sntrup1277 |
| 2405712 | 2417441 | 2437696 | T: C:lake1 |
| 2423411 | 2432514 | 2441007 | T: frodokem976 |
| 2452175 | 2459208 | 2466634 | T: ledakem1464 |
| 2557346 | 2561170 | 2568374 | T: C:lake2 |
| 2696022 | 2702306 | 2708875 | T: C:lake3 |
| 2775000 | 2782810 | 2793307 | T: limasp1306cca |
| 2846897 | 2849631 | 2852676 | T: C:ledakemcpa32 |
| 2888806 | 2896149 | 2902710 | T: frodokem976aes |
| 2886287 | 2910062 | 2934247 | T: C:edonk192k48n144nu4l4 |
| 2914674 | 2932643 | 2940394 | T: C:ledakemcpa53 |
| 2959273 | 2964455 | 2978514 | T: limasp1822cca |
| 3305053 | 3310056 | 3344553 | T: ledakem1364 |
| 3408929 | 3416962 | 3480112 | T: frodokem640shake |
| 3459883 | 3473328 | 3572250 | T: ledakem1264 |
| 3509443 | 3531119 | 3547049 | T: C:ledakemcpa54 |
| 4255527 | 4275301 | 4344293 | T: locker1 |
| 4327683 | 4337330 | 4349135 | T: rolloii128 |
| 4362197 | 4364945 | 4368720 | T: rolloii192 |
| 4176688? | 4414174? | 5594144? | T: ledakem14sl |
| 3794593? | 4539405? | 5332660? | T: ledakem13sl |
| 4765973 | 4778191 | 4801398 | T: locker2 |
| 4820770 | 4841647 | 4952288 | T: frodokem1344aes |
| 5108178 | 5112193 | 5115774 | T: rolloii256 |
| 5194317 | 5213039 | 5276147 | T: locker3 |
| 5255219 | 5269625 | 5277042 | T: limasp2062cca |
| 5658977 | 5685790 | 5702473 | T: locker4 |
| 5770815? | 5791511? | 8016703? | T: ledakem3464 |
| 5786733 | 5884318 | 6447790 | T: ledakem12sl |
| 5874327 | 5916008 | 5947915 | T: sikep434 |
| 6144698 | 6151245 | 6268442 | T: C:ledakemcpa52 |
| 6446795 | 6493695 | 6553688 | T: remblem1056 |
| 6517367 | 6525422 | 6534522 | T: locker6 |
| 6572892 | 6579086 | 6609554 | T: remblem928 |
| 6622694 | 6718478 | 6874835 | T: ramstakers216091 |
| 7140772 | 7184994 | 7308437 | T: ledakem3364 |
| 7251990 | 7257068 | 7263081 | T: frodokem976shake |
| 7688011 | 7705515 | 7722897 | T: locker5 |
| 7913111 | 7939819 | 8316945 | T: ledakem3264 |
| 8093344 | 8101552 | 8184529 | T: sikep503 |
| 9369760 | 9489780 | 9739031 | T: ledakem33sl |
| 9516981 | 9537348 | 11009508 | T: ledakem34sl |
| 9390507 | 9612241 | 9673835 | T: lotus128 |
| 9592141 | 9820207 | 10466438 | T: sikep434comp |
| 10881687 | 10915929 | 10975557 | T: ledakem5464 |
| 11037772 | 11051734 | 11077445 | T: locker7 |
| 11288928 | 11632925 | 12615638 | T: ledakem32sl |
| 11905921 | 11918085 | 11934812 | T: locker8 |
| 12725053 | 12760350 | 12792367 | T: locker9 |
| 13005916 | 13235473 | 13402000 | T: ledakem5364 |
| 12830838 | 13292474 | 13974485 | T: frodokem1344shake |
| 13249948 | 13558540 | 14545505 | T: sikep503comp |
| 14203769 | 14538070 | 17603807 | T: ledakem54sl |
| 14731396 | 14736740 | 14765066 | T: sikep610 |
| 17498534 | 17829687 | 18094807 | T: lotus192 |
| 19233331 | 19383203 | 22223256 | T: ledakem53sl |
| 20297662 | 20324055 | 20360678 | T: mersenne756839 |
| 19713168 | 20557494 | 21860495 | T: ledakem5264 |
| 24949596 | 24967635 | 25027596 | T: sikep751 |
| 25630380 | 25809027 | 27447610 | T: sikep610comp |
| 29173845 | 29479446 | 29805135 | mceliece348864f |
| 29406027 | 29608188 | 29900960 | mceliece348864pcf |
| 29365446 | 29638764 | 29883567 | T: ramstakers756839 |
| 29566934 | 31072209 | 33297529 | T: lotus256 |
| 32056486 | 32864582 | 34673863 | T: ledakem52sl |
| 39265871 | 39301637 | 41670218 | T: sikep751comp |
| 41741646 | 42087811 | 42651282 | T: ntskem1264 |
| 31922053? | 44501743? | 67472434? | mceliece348864 |
| 32563985? | 44625990? | 62761010? | mceliece348864pc |
| 51057283? | 78368300? | 127120218? | T: rsa2048 |
| 97754931 | 98006423 | 100046894 | mceliece460896f |
| 95084367 | 98049905 | 98341580 | mceliece460896pcf |
| 99003205 | 100175794 | 101493035 | T: ntskem1380 |
| 111322896? | 146851257? | 219942266? | mceliece460896pc |
| 112360335? | 149842524? | 241310015? | mceliece460896 |
| 184255731 | 185604241 | 188877018 | mceliece6960119f |
| 190282078 | 191053965 | 191902812 | mceliece6960119pcf |
| 225772679 | 228286662 | 230322027 | mceliece6688128f |
| 227146591 | 228501882 | 230592740 | mceliece6688128pcf |
| 243264524 | 243941518 | 244489235 | mceliece8192128f |
| 243691264 | 246691098 | 249115218 | mceliece8192128pcf |
| 247474435 | 248029944 | 249602327 | T: oddmanhattan128 |
| 263447329 | 264085292 | 265289377 | T: ntskem13136 |
| 221215238? | 273443165? | 395263786? | mceliece6960119 |
| 222644911? | 291829748? | 416461796? | mceliece6960119pc |
| 248008887? | 323999110? | 470415885? | mceliece6688128pc |
| 264579670? | 344960087? | 492353881? | mceliece6688128 |
| 256749451? | 351308852? | 494907436? | mceliece8192128 |
| 277465055? | 358951012? | 475877685? | mceliece8192128pc |
| 394929737 | 395956202 | 397048839 | T: oddmanhattan192 |
| 703929321 | 705111774 | 707595084 | T: oddmanhattan256 |
| 855293786 | 864251255 | 868070355 | T: bigquake1 |
| 3140325464 | 3221971030 | 3294089290 | T: pqrsa15 |
| 7144901517 | 7215681325 | 7424243219 | T: bigquake3 |
| 12830949059 | 13002302065 | 13157464304 | T: bigquake5 |
|
| Cycles for encapsulation |
| 25% | 50% | 75% | system |
| 14310 | 15028 | 15722 | T: rsa2048 |
| 21405 | 21598 | 22165 | ntruhps2048509 |
| 21616 | 21649 | 21708 | smaugt1 |
| 21766 | 21819 | 21874 | timer |
| 22355 | 22404 | 22548 | ntruplus576 |
| 22955 | 22984 | 23059 | smaugt1v5 |
| 23219 | 23306 | 23419 | ntruhrss701 |
| 24450 | 24526 | 24651 | mlkem512 |
| 25760 | 25817 | 26138 | ntruplus768 |
| 27361 | 28214 | 29957 | mceliece348864 |
| 28916 | 29363 | 30044 | kyber90s512 |
| 29513 | 29568 | 29843 | ntruplus864 |
| 27960 | 29625 | 31429 | mceliece348864f |
| 30749 | 30979 | 31624 | ntruhps2048677 |
| 32761 | 33859 | 36052 | mceliece348864pcf |
| 34330 | 34565 | 35929 | kyber512 |
| 33234 | 34574 | 36319 | mceliece348864pc |
| 36250 | 36545 | 37052 | ntruhps4096821 |
| 37899 | 38457 | 38783 | sntrup653 |
| 38256 | 38457 | 38656 | mlkem768 |
| 39312 | 39410 | 39889 | ntruplus1152 |
| 39182 | 39506 | 39985 | smaugt3v5 |
| 39378 | 39914 | 40779 | kyber90s768 |
| 39763 | 40116 | 40543 | sntrup4591761 |
| 41808 | 41873 | 42158 | sntrup761 |
| 45279 | 45425 | 45706 | smaugt3 |
| 45945 | 46114 | 46678 | T: C:nhcompact512cca |
| 46580 | 46623 | 46676 | T: lightsaber2 |
| 51149 | 51731 | 51832 | sntrup857 |
| 51627 | 51890 | 53837 | kyber768 |
| 52584 | 52852 | 54286 | kyber90s1024 |
| 55007 | 55278 | 55711 | mlkem1024 |
| 55538 | 55639 | 56140 | sntrup953 |
| 57122 | 57656 | 58076 | sntrup1013 |
| 57564 | 58378 | 58874 | timerv5 |
| 60361 | 60503 | 60656 | threebears624r2cca |
| 60560 | 60618 | 60722 | threebears624r2ccax |
| 57415 | 61049 | 68498 | mceliece460896 |
| 61399 | 61520 | 61813 | smaugt5v5 |
| 61797 | 61847 | 61984 | C:threebears624r2cpa |
| 61769 | 61864 | 62002 | C:threebears624r2cpax |
| 62009 | 62192 | 62942 | smaugt5 |
| 62329 | 62492 | 62815 | ntrulpr653 |
| 58907 | 63857 | 73476 | mceliece460896f |
| 64759 | 64834 | 65005 | ntrulpr761 |
| 65039 | 65128 | 65356 | T: C:nhcompact768cca |
| 66484 | 68069 | 70166 | T: lac128 |
| 67946 | 68423 | 69282 | T: ntrulpr4591761 |
| 64415 | 68527 | 75975 | mceliece460896pcf |
| 64399 | 70032 | 79901 | mceliece460896pc |
| 71669 | 71801 | 71963 | sntrup1277 |
| 72276 | 72872 | 73976 | kyber1024 |
| 77067 | 77325 | 77961 | T!!!newhope512cca |
| 77769 | 78042 | 78448 | T: C:r5nd1kem0d |
| 78674 | 78732 | 78841 | T: saber2 |
| 82494 | 82641 | 82820 | ntrulpr857 |
| 82781 | 83162 | 83634 | T: C:ledakemcpa14 |
| 84790 | 84901 | 85383 | T: C:nhcompact1024cca |
| 84805 | 85193 | 86116 | T: C:ledakemcpa13 |
| 85872 | 85939 | 86058 | ntrulpr953 |
| 87011 | 87109 | 87228 | ntrulpr1013 |
| 91568 | 92924 | 94823 | T: C:ledakemcpa12 |
| 95756 | 97945 | 99897 | T: ntskem1264 |
| 98320 | 98453 | 98648 | threebears936r2ccax |
| 98380 | 98465 | 98668 | threebears936r2cca |
| 95904 | 99636 | 105854 | mceliece6688128f |
| 97184 | 101460 | 108794 | mceliece6688128 |
| 105142 | 105297 | 105504 | C:threebears936r2cpa |
| 106520 | 106664 | 106816 | C:threebears936r2cpax |
| 103683 | 107086 | 113557 | mceliece6960119 |
| 104010 | 107258 | 116866 | T: C:edonk128k16n80nu4l6 |
| 106711 | 107455 | 108156 | T: C:r5nd1kem5d |
| 104876 | 108652 | 116074 | mceliece6688128pc |
| 103875 | 108764 | 117334 | mceliece6688128pcf |
| 105046 | 108915 | 114930 | mceliece6960119f |
| 108389 | 109151 | 110598 | T: C:r5nd0kem2iot |
| 108733 | 109377 | 110338 | T: C:bikel1 |
| 110533 | 111068 | 111980 | T: C:r5nd1kem4longkey |
| 111425 | 111696 | 112024 | ntrulpr1277 |
| 112391 | 114652 | 116521 | mceliece8192128 |
| 116903 | 116978 | 117191 | T: firesaber2 |
| 118480 | 119447 | 120903 | mceliece8192128f |
| 118566 | 122543 | 128485 | mceliece6960119pcf |
| 119417 | 123472 | 130171 | mceliece6960119pc |
| 126405 | 128745 | 132298 | T: ntrukem443 |
| 127008 | 128840 | 131162 | mceliece8192128pc |
| 128823 | 130283 | 132090 | mceliece8192128pcf |
| 138813 | 141732 | 143461 | T: lac192 |
| 144754 | 145048 | 145641 | T!!!newhope1024cca |
| 145043 | 145574 | 146243 | T: lotus128 |
| 148341 | 148463 | 148677 | threebears1248r2cca |
| 149475 | 149653 | 149918 | threebears1248r2ccax |
| 156987 | 157151 | 157377 | C:threebears1248r2cpa |
| 158502 | 158623 | 158943 | C:threebears1248r2cpax |
| 160714 | 161443 | 162393 | T: C:rolloi128 |
| 162087 | 164563 | 165359 | T: lac256 |
| 169502 | 170254 | 171254 | T: C:r5nd3kem5d |
| 181001 | 182111 | 183749 | T: C:rolloi192 |
| 193355 | 194545 | 196077 | T: C:ledakemcpa34 |
| 197757 | 198850 | 199773 | T: C:ledakemcpa33 |
| 206535 | 208055 | 216781 | T: lotus192 |
| 209743 | 210399 | 211429 | T: C:rolloi256 |
| 210165 | 211538 | 215811 | T: ledakem1464 |
| 220536 | 220690 | 221005 | T: hqc128round4 |
| 222999 | 223237 | 223875 | T: saberx4 |
| 227478 | 227973 | 228938 | T: ledakem1264 |
| 228797 | 231333 | 235216 | T: ntrukem743 |
| 232272 | 235668 | 244377 | T: C:edonk128k16n80nu8l6 |
| 235032 | 235986 | 237211 | T: C:hila5 |
| 232665 | 237945 | 242812 | T: C:ledakemcpa32 |
| 250813 | 251992 | 254175 | T: C:bikel3 |
| 272954 | 273323 | 273711 | T: ledakem1364 |
| 280781 | 281980 | 283186 | T: C:r5nd3kem0d |
| 289102 | 289316 | 289703 | T: ledakem13sl |
| 291347 | 294613 | 302655 | T: C:edonk128k32n96nu4l4 |
| 301883 | 303689 | 305288 | T: C:r5nd5kem5d |
| 308459 | 310990 | 326289 | T: ntskem1380 |
| 291221 | 312945 | 334565 | T: lotus256 |
| 317666 | 318469 | 319509 | T: kindi256342 |
| 325164 | 326054 | 326984 | T: ledakem12sl |
| 337920 | 339207 | 340616 | T: ntskem13136 |
| 338330 | 340178 | 341844 | T: C:r5nd5kem0d |
| 356337 | 357037 | 365292 | T: ledakem14sl |
| 380427 | 381458 | 382003 | T: kindi512222 |
| 406907 | 416579 | 419959 | T: kindi512241 |
| 429980 | 431862 | 438888 | T: C:ledakemcpa54 |
| 439168 | 445302 | 454229 | T: C:edonk128ref |
| 445700 | 448557 | 455667 | T: C:lake1 |
| 442798 | 451359 | 453164 | T: C:ledakemcpa53 |
| 463602 | 464788 | 467254 | T: lima2p1024cca |
| 458915 | 465284 | 473244 | T: C:ledakemcpa52 |
| 479621 | 481544 | 486387 | T: C:r5n11kem0d |
| 491749 | 492714 | 497393 | T: hqc192round4 |
| 492600 | 494457 | 497194 | T: C:lake2 |
| 511095 | 512562 | 531638 | T: hqcrmrs128 |
| 531930 | 532542 | 533398 | T: ledakem3264 |
| 531499 | 533143 | 534132 | T: ledakem3464 |
| 532521 | 533558 | 535100 | T: rolloii128 |
| 548559 | 549576 | 550950 | T: rolloii192 |
| 553427 | 555815 | 558337 | T: C:lake3 |
| 547092 | 558522 | 571465 | T: hqc128 |
| 593374 | 594831 | 595832 | T: ledakem3364 |
| 604294 | 605363 | 606775 | T: rolloii256 |
| 632797 | 635924 | 639746 | T: C:edonk192k32n128nu4l6 |
| 654898 | 668431 | 678540 | T: hqc1281 |
| 662887 | 685907 | 687001 | T: titaniumccatoy |
| 710036 | 710932 | 711718 | T: kindi512321 |
| 709839 | 712498 | 713711 | T: ledakem32sl |
| 754139 | 763617 | 775460 | T: locker1 |
| 779543 | 785780 | 791290 | T: locker2 |
| 819072 | 825901 | 834144 | T: C:edonk192k48n144nu4l4 |
| 828104 | 829593 | 841888 | T: ledakem33sl |
| 860168 | 862982 | 871541 | T: kindi256522 |
| 864287 | 865911 | 897029 | T: titaniumccalite |
| 879517 | 885350 | 899091 | T: locker3 |
| 932656 | 934501 | 936224 | T: C:r5n13kem0d |
| 933852 | 935534 | 936525 | T: hqc256round4 |
| 937531 | 939068 | 940521 | T: lima2p2048cca |
| 989388 | 994492 | 1001920 | T: locker4 |
| 1008981 | 1014133 | 1058484 | T: titaniumccastd |
| 1015554 | 1017272 | 1018933 | T: ledakem34sl |
| 1034759 | 1044487 | 1067939 | T: hqcrmrs192 |
| 1055383 | 1058105 | 1062705 | T: rqc128 |
| 1086769 | 1090432 | 1094195 | T: locker6 |
| 1129563 | 1149328 | 1169053 | T: hqc192 |
| 1203733 | 1205482 | 1238692 | T: ledakem5364 |
| 1178748 | 1207442 | 1226157 | T: hqc1921 |
| 1256571 | 1259006 | 1264454 | T: locker5 |
| 1261220 | 1263988 | 1273167 | T: ledakem5464 |
| 1276876 | 1278084 | 1279626 | T: limasp1018cca |
| 1282820 | 1301569 | 1334436 | T: hqc1922 |
| 1312775 | 1315099 | 1319196 | T: ledakem5264 |
| 1300244 | 1343968 | 1345394 | T: titaniumccamed |
| 1415464 | 1420608 | 1424677 | T: ledakem54sl |
| 1484775 | 1493913 | 1498575 | T: titaniumccahi |
| 1627168 | 1629473 | 1631825 | T: frodokem640 |
| 1705971 | 1739147 | 1767882 | T: hqcrmrs256 |
| 1774891 | 1783961 | 1801308 | T: ledakem53sl |
| 1812733 | 1815911 | 1831285 | T: frodokem640aes |
| 1858426 | 1864576 | 1883108 | T: locker7 |
| 1831580 | 1866725 | 1902184 | T: hqc2561 |
| 1851934 | 1876441 | 1907604 | T: hqc256 |
| 1878734 | 1887949 | 1892612 | T: ledakem52sl |
| 1898703 | 1908491 | 1933328 | T: locker8 |
| 1943272 | 1951880 | 1960574 | T: C:r5n15kem0d |
| 1925771 | 1953602 | 1986647 | T: hqc2562 |
| 2073784 | 2078247 | 2085209 | T: locker9 |
| 2033102 | 2089616 | 2091446 | T: titaniumccasuper |
| 2100495 | 2138355 | 2169594 | T: hqc2563 |
| 2425859 | 2430518 | 2438409 | T: limasp1306cca |
| 2358868 | 2432802 | 2501745 | T: bigquake1 |
| 2446524 | 2449396 | 2453053 | T: rqc192 |
| 2590952 | 2594176 | 2597714 | T: rqc256 |
| 2613604 | 2617513 | 2619503 | T: limasp1822cca |
| 3271542 | 3273679 | 3277546 | T: frodokem976 |
| 3528925 | 3531416 | 3535980 | T: frodokem976aes |
| 3674630 | 3691639 | 3755046 | T: frodokem640shake |
| 4888294 | 4928500 | 4939501 | T: limasp2062cca |
| 5946410 | 5956532 | 6131234 | T: frodokem1344aes |
| 7303765 | 7544278 | 7828070 | T: bigquake3 |
| 7621393 | 7640201 | 7930718 | T: frodokem976shake |
| 9566979 | 9577067 | 9619909 | T: sikep434 |
| 9594054 | 9623781 | 9726893 | T: remblem1056 |
| 9771466 | 9780664 | 9793858 | T: remblem928 |
| 11270056 | 11640076 | 12010770 | T: bigquake5 |
| 12199846 | 12490184 | 12712608 | T: ramstakers216091 |
| 13253628 | 13262319 | 13387341 | T: sikep503 |
| 13515581 | 13712832 | 14160378 | T: frodokem1344shake |
| 14984806 | 15038960 | 15115090 | T: sikep434comp |
| 16943106 | 17005082 | 17048821 | T: pqrsa15 |
| 19590601 | 19690553 | 19745301 | T: mersenne756839 |
| 20583606 | 20638250 | 20735395 | T: sikep503comp |
| 27070380 | 27103974 | 27107772 | T: sikep610 |
| 37578691 | 37708980 | 37877350 | T: sikep610comp |
| 40387878 | 40425587 | 40469837 | T: sikep751 |
| 53259146 | 53520749 | 53712748 | T: oddmanhattan128 |
| 53652512 | 54047688 | 54454045 | T: ramstakers756839 |
| 62811095 | 62965616 | 63213835 | T: sikep751comp |
| 102325883 | 102548516 | 102766249 | T: oddmanhattan192 |
| 211747958 | 212765042 | 213684968 | T: oddmanhattan256 |
|
| Cycles for decapsulation |
| 25% | 50% | 75% | system |
| 16622 | 16642 | 16682 | C:threebears624r2cpax |
| 18131 | 18167 | 18230 | ntruplus768 |
| 20603 | 20880 | 21422 | kyber90s512 |
| 21019 | 21068 | 21149 | ntruplus864 |
| 21277 | 21329 | 21408 | ntruplus576 |
| 21376 | 21436 | 21487 | C:threebears936r2cpax |
| 25677 | 25719 | 25761 | mlkem512 |
| 25921 | 25953 | 25991 | C:threebears1248r2cpax |
| 26937 | 27285 | 28790 | kyber512 |
| 27270 | 27310 | 27356 | C:threebears624r2cpa |
| 27516 | 27600 | 27756 | smaugt1v5 |
| 28540 | 28585 | 28662 | ntruplus1152 |
| 28324 | 28659 | 29132 | T: C:r5nd1kem0d |
| 28502 | 28687 | 29225 | kyber90s768 |
| 33121 | 33198 | 33356 | smaugt1 |
| 33949 | 33986 | 34050 | C:threebears936r2cpa |
| 34191 | 34236 | 34327 | timer |
| 36389 | 36452 | 36619 | ntruhps2048509 |
| 39587 | 39697 | 41754 | kyber90s1024 |
| 40026 | 40076 | 40223 | mlkem768 |
| 40141 | 40185 | 40269 | C:threebears1248r2cpa |
| 40028 | 40888 | 41117 | T: C:r5nd1kem5d |
| 40578 | 41155 | 41594 | T: C:r5nd0kem2iot |
| 41216 | 41997 | 43454 | kyber768 |
| 42467 | 42831 | 43193 | T: C:r5nd1kem4longkey |
| 44361 | 44618 | 45223 | T: C:nhcompact512cca |
| 45578 | 45626 | 45706 | T: lightsaber2 |
| 47069 | 47136 | 47384 | T: C:hila5 |
| 51222 | 51314 | 51475 | sntrup761 |
| 52783 | 52865 | 53002 | smaugt3v5 |
| 53040 | 53157 | 53426 | sntrup653 |
| 55811 | 55873 | 56124 | ntruhps2048677 |
| 55996 | 56158 | 56258 | ntruhrss701 |
| 57941 | 58189 | 58963 | mlkem1024 |
| 58818 | 58853 | 58931 | kyber1024 |
| 60881 | 61028 | 61438 | smaugt3 |
| 63945 | 64047 | 64237 | T: C:nhcompact768cca |
| 63752 | 65371 | 67609 | T: C:r5nd3kem5d |
| 69656 | 70224 | 70849 | ntruhps4096821 |
| 72435 | 72510 | 72606 | sntrup857 |
| 76406 | 76456 | 76534 | T: saber2 |
| 77103 | 77356 | 77580 | ntrulpr653 |
| 77279 | 77561 | 83387 | timerv5 |
| 77691 | 77813 | 77928 | sntrup953 |
| 79122 | 79210 | 79344 | sntrup1013 |
| 79478 | 79568 | 79743 | ntrulpr761 |
| 79544 | 79666 | 79908 | smaugt5v5 |
| 82503 | 82620 | 82888 | smaugt5 |
| 84447 | 84671 | 84926 | T: C:nhcompact1024cca |
| 84505 | 84744 | 85007 | T!!!newhope512cca |
| 85293 | 85378 | 85509 | threebears624r2ccax |
| 85247 | 85405 | 86025 | sntrup4591761 |
| 86948 | 88927 | 91160 | T: lac128 |
| 96698 | 96808 | 96998 | sntrup1277 |
| 97302 | 97625 | 98852 | T: ntrulpr4591761 |
| 102723 | 102861 | 103147 | ntrulpr857 |
| 106358 | 106473 | 106585 | ntrulpr953 |
| 106434 | 106541 | 106720 | ntrulpr1013 |
| 108875 | 108941 | 109155 | threebears624r2cca |
| 114832 | 114898 | 115067 | T: firesaber2 |
| 114662 | 115045 | 115429 | mceliece348864 |
| 115089 | 115320 | 115728 | mceliece348864f |
| 119984 | 120104 | 120292 | mceliece348864pcf |
| 119980 | 120340 | 121626 | mceliece348864pc |
| 128100 | 129597 | 136028 | T: C:r5nd5kem5d |
| 130468 | 130623 | 130771 | threebears936r2ccax |
| 130065 | 132043 | 134243 | T: C:r5nd3kem0d |
| 135866 | 136052 | 136574 | ntrulpr1277 |
| 137166 | 138050 | 139670 | T: ntrukem443 |
| 155988 | 158451 | 161044 | T: C:r5nd5kem0d |
| 159345 | 159780 | 160133 | T!!!newhope1024cca |
| 165112 | 165244 | 165454 | threebears936r2cca |
| 167474 | 167730 | 168323 | T: lotus128 |
| 171555 | 175916 | 177490 | T: C:r5n11kem0d |
| 188449 | 188561 | 188728 | threebears1248r2ccax |
| 193539 | 194529 | 197554 | T: lac192 |
| 226288 | 226471 | 226738 | threebears1248r2cca |
| 232323 | 232513 | 233289 | mceliece460896f |
| 232558 | 232981 | 234108 | mceliece460896 |
| 237857 | 238106 | 238653 | mceliece460896pcf |
| 237819 | 238126 | 238483 | T: saberx4 |
| 238764 | 239185 | 239829 | mceliece460896pc |
| 245943 | 248292 | 259550 | T: lotus192 |
| 256112 | 257063 | 257475 | T: C:r5n13kem0d |
| 263359 | 263820 | 264545 | mceliece6960119f |
| 263774 | 264196 | 264702 | mceliece6960119 |
| 266685 | 268128 | 271139 | mceliece6960119pc |
| 268054 | 268334 | 268613 | mceliece6960119pcf |
| 269568 | 270679 | 275541 | T: ntrukem743 |
| 278660 | 279101 | 279470 | mceliece8192128f |
| 281483 | 282024 | 282841 | mceliece6688128 |
| 282603 | 283321 | 284178 | mceliece8192128 |
| 282518 | 283429 | 284446 | mceliece6688128f |
| 287460 | 287867 | 288599 | mceliece8192128pcf |
| 287838 | 288580 | 289388 | mceliece8192128pc |
| 289106 | 290237 | 291228 | mceliece6688128pc |
| 289605 | 290496 | 291242 | mceliece6688128pcf |
| 310522 | 313217 | 316837 | T: lac256 |
| 346400 | 354387 | 397404 | T: lotus256 |
| 380655 | 380912 | 381488 | T: hqc128round4 |
| 395738 | 396246 | 397398 | T: kindi256342 |
| 498716 | 499759 | 501110 | T: kindi512222 |
| 546844 | 547989 | 549584 | T: kindi512241 |
| 555543 | 556882 | 562483 | T: ntskem1264 |
| 595158 | 596839 | 598108 | T: lima2p1024cca |
| 649960 | 652675 | 661722 | T: C:ledakemcpa12 |
| 682158 | 692234 | 844297 | T: C:ledakemcpa13 |
| 767524 | 768651 | 795606 | T: titaniumccatoy |
| 789089 | 791543 | 802717 | T: hqc192round4 |
| 829992? | 836700? | 1043370? | T: C:ledakemcpa14 |
| 849144 | 850963 | 853198 | T: C:r5n15kem0d |
| 843284 | 859909 | 862177 | T: hqc128 |
| 860630 | 872218 | 876685 | T: hqcrmrs128 |
| 880796 | 882984 | 884721 | T: kindi512321 |
| 1005363 | 1007426 | 1008748 | T: kindi256522 |
| 1008226 | 1033962 | 1037687 | T: titaniumccalite |
| 1095404 | 1096651 | 1097609 | T: ntskem1380 |
| 1156388 | 1164583 | 1212641 | T: hqc1281 |
| 1183705 | 1187266 | 1191428 | T: C:rolloi128 |
| 1192690 | 1194783 | 1196695 | T: lima2p2048cca |
| 1174843 | 1215952 | 1216755 | T: titaniumccastd |
| 1328264 | 1331242 | 1337934 | T: C:rolloi192 |
| 1472096 | 1475862 | 1511832 | T: titaniumccamed |
| 1538386 | 1540678 | 1543270 | T: hqc256round4 |
| 1555106 | 1558203 | 1580718 | T: C:bikel1 |
| 1558390 | 1576288 | 1612407 | T: hqcrmrs192 |
| 1575091 | 1601482 | 1617644 | T: hqc192 |
| 1623269 | 1624796 | 1626650 | T: frodokem640 |
| 1642486 | 1661790 | 1669686 | T: limasp1018cca |
| 1722976 | 1732911 | 1739271 | T: titaniumccahi |
| 1742497 | 1744168 | 1747064 | T: frodokem640aes |
| 1775198 | 1785477 | 1798104 | T: C:ledakemcpa32 |
| 1836870 | 1840218 | 1844742 | T: rolloii128 |
| 1851163 | 1858240 | 1867031 | T: ledakem1264 |
| 1854803 | 1879388 | 1929338 | T: hqc1921 |
| 1891904 | 1895947 | 1901190 | T: C:lake1 |
| 1941635 | 1960312 | 1963988 | T: hqc1922 |
| 1996525 | 2002126 | 2009394 | T: ledakem1364 |
| 2026233 | 2030064 | 2033608 | T: rolloii192 |
| 2052932 | 2058286 | 2063494 | T: ledakem1464 |
| 2090926 | 2096092 | 2159130 | T: rsa2048 |
| 2213950 | 2217711 | 2222566 | T: C:rolloi256 |
| 2226155 | 2228604 | 2231617 | T: C:ledakemcpa33 |
| 2353675 | 2405224 | 2406804 | T: titaniumccasuper |
| 2406997 | 2410440 | 2413509 | T: ledakem13sl |
| 2532506 | 2537641 | 2626729 | T: hqc256 |
| 2521464 | 2554508 | 2599538 | T: hqcrmrs256 |
| 2599142 | 2601855 | 2604791 | T: ntskem13136 |
| 2605078 | 2609062 | 2612534 | T: rolloii256 |
| 2618742 | 2628143 | 2654484 | T: ledakem12sl |
| 2188974 | 2668906 | 2673073 | T: C:ledakemcpa34 |
| 2729881 | 2757209 | 2761789 | T: hqc2561 |
| 2758189 | 2771785 | 2790093 | T: ledakem14sl |
| 2797125 | 2841473 | 2867303 | T: hqc2562 |
| 3147870 | 3169131 | 3195399 | T: hqc2563 |
| 3186481 | 3198391 | 3207547 | T: limasp1306cca |
| 3159348 | 3236834 | 3245782 | T: bigquake1 |
| 3023004 | 3251503 | 3394388 | T: C:edonk128k32n96nu4l4 |
| 3259518 | 3265385 | 3275305 | T: C:lake2 |
| 3275665 | 3278593 | 3280577 | T: frodokem976 |
| 3378715 | 3382631 | 3386193 | T: limasp1822cca |
| 3381817 | 3383813 | 3388300 | T: frodokem976aes |
| 3554363 | 3562410 | 3574392 | T: frodokem640shake |
| 3645856 | 3650919 | 3660738 | T: rqc128 |
| 3783515 | 3793332 | 3834535 | T: locker1 |
| 3906044 | 3921578 | 3947402 | T: locker2 |
| 3566075? | 4023409? | 7696677? | T: C:edonk192k48n144nu4l4 |
| 4292594 | 4301012 | 4314227 | T: locker4 |
| 4467778 | 4482400 | 4500772 | T: C:lake3 |
| 4862285 | 4872666 | 4961200 | T: C:bikel3 |
| 5035345 | 5059668 | 5080631 | T: C:ledakemcpa52 |
| 5282987 | 5298775 | 5327801 | T: ledakem3264 |
| 5393700 | 5430069 | 5480727 | T: C:ledakemcpa53 |
| 5440446 | 5456321 | 5585896 | T: ledakem3464 |
| 5442127 | 5477771 | 5511321 | T: ledakem3364 |
| 5757108 | 5762829 | 5952782 | T: frodokem1344aes |
| 5846733 | 5866127 | 5982288 | T: locker3 |
| 4822366 | 5938673 | 5954327 | T: C:ledakemcpa54 |
| 6316939 | 6325148 | 6335225 | T: locker6 |
| 6398151 | 6406421 | 6494631 | T: limasp2062cca |
| 6560052 | 6575007 | 6585287 | T: locker5 |
| 6821884 | 6837173 | 6873292 | T: ledakem32sl |
| 7039899 | 7067380 | 7089239 | T: locker7 |
| 7206942 | 7227205 | 7246246 | T: locker8 |
| 7395031 | 7420493 | 7609022 | T: frodokem976shake |
| 7971162 | 7988470 | 8110541 | T: ledakem33sl |
| 8070853 | 8079353 | 8089620 | T: rqc192 |
| 8689204 | 8756075 | 8849128 | T: ledakem34sl |
| 9799450 | 9820968 | 9834950 | T: locker9 |
| 10263580 | 10264490 | 10319220 | T: sikep434 |
| 10853526 | 10865346 | 10877877 | T: rqc256 |
| 10912929 | 10945678 | 10951709 | T: sikep434comp |
| 11832973 | 11864772 | 11881814 | T: ledakem5264 |
| 12302384 | 12390935 | 12563585 | T: ledakem5364 |
| 12854900 | 12929353 | 13092753 | T: remblem1056 |
| 13015010 | 13022980 | 13073016 | T: frodokem1344shake |
| 13120155 | 13130345 | 13184672 | T: remblem928 |
| 14193447 | 14196621 | 14204310 | T: sikep503 |
| 14233043 | 14329099 | 14413221 | T: ledakem5464 |
| 15119594 | 15135046 | 15152125 | T: sikep503comp |
| 16954617 | 17098619 | 17212736 | T: ledakem53sl |
| 17060061 | 17221417 | 17325548 | T: ledakem52sl |
| 17163329 | 17225980 | 17280084 | T: ledakem54sl |
| 25529326 | 25562821 | 26167532 | T: ramstakers216091 |
| 27256570 | 27329393 | 27598494 | T: sikep610 |
| 28099143 | 28577649 | 29388482 | T: bigquake3 |
| 28929077 | 28931983 | 29012220 | T: sikep610comp |
| 28718720 | 29162735 | 29217669 | T: mersenne756839 |
| 21305977? | 34081930? | 48232561? | T: C:edonk128k16n80nu4l6 |
| 13029329? | 36131831? | 95053222? | T: C:edonk128ref |
| 34227238? | 42940914? | 61015512? | T: C:edonk192k32n128nu4l6 |
| 43433618 | 43437223 | 43553912 | T: sikep751 |
| 43908281 | 44194925 | 46319439 | T: bigquake5 |
| 45967645 | 45971652 | 46030189 | T: sikep751comp |
| 57684527 | 57943346 | 58509178 | T: oddmanhattan128 |
| 74894882? | 77621879? | 167695280? | T: C:edonk128k16n80nu8l6 |
| 104341407 | 104520617 | 105009589 | T: ramstakers756839 |
| 105829946 | 105874094 | 105994098 | T: pqrsa15 |
| 111859506 | 112208481 | 112721415 | T: oddmanhattan192 |
| 231559918 | 232434522 | 232750070 | T: oddmanhattan256 |
|
|
|